{ "version": "riddle-proof.profile-result.v1", "profile_name": "lilarcade-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search-generated-prelim-candidate", "runner": "local-playwright", "status": "passed", "baseline_policy": "invariant_only", "route": { "requested": "https://main.dlwavl00q582x.amplifyapp.com/games/drum-sequencer?song=monkberry-moon-delight-tab&mix=profile&view=trainer&instrument=bass", "observed": "/games/drum-sequencer", "expected_path": "/games/drum-sequencer", "matched": true, "http_status": 200 }, "artifacts": { "screenshots": [ "lilarcade-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search-generated-prelim-candidate-desktop", "lilarcade-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search-generated-prelim-candidate-desktop-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search", "screenshots/lilarcade-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search-generated-prelim-candidate-desktop-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search.png", "screenshots/lilarcade-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search-generated-prelim-candidate-desktop.png" ], "console": "console.json", "proof_json": "proof.json", "dom_summary": "dom-summary.json", "riddle_artifacts": [ { "name": "proof.json", "path": "proof.json", "kind": "text", "source": "artifacts" }, { "name": "console.json", "path": "console.json", "kind": "text", "source": "artifacts" }, { "name": "dom-summary.json", "path": "dom-summary.json", "kind": "text", "source": "artifacts" }, { "name": "lilarcade-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search-generated-prelim-candidate-desktop-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search.png", "path": "screenshots/lilarcade-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search-generated-prelim-candidate-desktop-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search.png", "kind": "screenshot", "source": "artifacts" }, { "name": "lilarcade-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search-generated-prelim-candidate-desktop.png", "path": "screenshots/lilarcade-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search-generated-prelim-candidate-desktop.png", "kind": "screenshot", "source": "artifacts" } ] }, "checks": [ { "type": "setup_actions_succeeded", "label": "setup actions succeeded", "status": "passed", "evidence": { "action_count": 7, "viewports": [ { "name": "desktop", "expected_action_count": 7, "ok": true, "result_count": 7 } ], "setup_summary": { "viewport_count": 1, "action_count": 7, "final_screenshot_count": 1, "final_screenshot_full_page": null, "final_screenshot_mode": null, "viewports": [ { "name": "desktop", "expected_action_count": 7, "ok": true, "result_count": 7, "observed_path": "/games/drum-sequencer", "final_url": "https://main.dlwavl00q582x.amplifyapp.com/games/drum-sequencer?song=monkberry-moon-delight-tab&mix=profile&view=trainer&instrument=bass", "action_counts": { "window_eval": 1, "assert_window_value": 4, "window_call": 1, "screenshot": 1 }, "frame_action_count": 0, "frame_urls": [], "final_screenshot": "lilarcade-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search-generated-prelim-candidate-desktop", "final_screenshot_full_page": null, "setup_screenshots": [ "lilarcade-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search-generated-prelim-candidate-desktop-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search" ], "clicked_total": 0, "clicked_truncated": false, "click_sequence_total": 0, "click_sequence_truncated": false, "click_sequences": [], "click_count_action_total": 0, "click_count_value_total": 0, "window_call_until_total": 0, "window_call_until_call_total": 0, "window_call_until_truncated": false, "window_call_until": [], "window_call_total": 1, "window_call_stored_total": 1, "window_call_captured_total": 1, "window_call_truncated": false, "window_call": [ { "ordinal": 2, "ok": true, "path": "__NEON_MIX_PROOF__.runRatchetLoop", "return_captured": true, "return_stored_to": "__neonMixProof.ratchetLoop", "reason": null, "returned": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "neon-ratchet-loop", "status": "claim_candidate_supported", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "domain": "audio_mix", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "candidateKind": "change_claim_candidate", "focusTracks": [ "guitar" ], "requestConstraints": { "targetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "direction": "down", "source": "explicit_args", "requestedText": "turn the guitar part down a little" }, "maxIterations": 3, "restore": true, "applyBest": false, "baselineCandidateRankingMetric": 61.66285, "bestCandidateRankingMetric": 62.2099, "rankingMetricDelta": -0.547, "supportedClaimCandidateCount": 3, "preparationReceipt": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "sample-source-preparation", "sources": { "drums": "samples", "bass": "hybrid", "chord": "hybrid", "guitar": "hybrid", "vocal": "voice_oohs" }, "loaded": { "drums": true, "vocal": true, "bass": true, "chord": true, "guitar": true }, "skipped": {}, "states": { "bass": { "source": "hybrid", "status": "idle", "loadedSampleCount": 6, "library": { "name": "tonejs-instruments bass-electric", "license": "CC BY 3.0", "sampleCount": 6 } }, "chord": { "source": "hybrid", "status": "idle", "loadedSampleCount": 7, "library": { "name": "tonejs-instruments piano", "license": "CC BY 3.0", "sampleCount": 7 } }, "guitar": { "source": "hybrid", "status": "idle", "loadedSampleCount": 9, "library": { "name": "tonejs-instruments guitar-electric", "license": "CC BY 3.0", "sampleCount": 9 } }, "vocal": { "source": "voice_oohs", "status": "idle", "loadedSampleCount": 37, "library": { "name": "FluidR3 General MIDI SoundFont", "license": "CC BY 3.0", "instruments": [ "voice_oohs", "choir_aahs", "lead_6_voice", "synth_choir" ] } }, "drums": { "source": "samples", "status": "idle", "loadedTrackCount": 5, "loadedSampleCount": 8, "loadedSampleNames": [ "snare-m", "kick", "kick-alt", "stick-m", "hhclosed-long", "hhclosed-short", "hhclosed", "clap" ], "library": { "name": "LM-2 sampled drum machine", "license": "Public domain sample pack", "trackCount": 5, "sampleCount": 8, "sampleNames": [ "kick", "kick-alt", "snare-m", "hhclosed-short", "hhclosed", "hhclosed-long", "clap", "stick-m" ] } } } }, "baseline": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "offline-audio-window-set", "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } }, "windowCount": 2, "passedCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "status": "passed", "windows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "bass", "active": true, "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "active": true, "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "active": true, "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.1115, "peak": 0.7747, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.22, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 71.0141, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -5.993, "slopePenalty": 0.5538, "rolloffPenalty": 2.8473, "presenceRatio": 0.0451, "presencePenalty": 0.8398, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.122, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2159, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 71.0141, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -5.993, "slopePenalty": 0.5538, "rolloffPenalty": 2.8473, "presenceRatio": 0.0451, "presencePenalty": 0.8398, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.122, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2159, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 6, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1772, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.011746 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1014, "peak": 0.5843, "totalEnergy": 0.00364 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0113, "peak": 0.124, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 } ], "error": null }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "active": true, "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.2921, "peak": 0.7726, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.24, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 52.3116, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.824, "slopePenalty": 2.0652, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1712, "presenceRatio": 0.0386, "presencePenalty": 0.9117, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3252, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.3009, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 52.3116, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.824, "slopePenalty": 2.0652, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1712, "presenceRatio": 0.0386, "presencePenalty": 0.9117, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3252, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.3009, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 7, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1638, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.010533 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1085, "peak": 0.6418, "totalEnergy": 0.00468 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0112, "peak": 0.1242, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0264, "peak": 0.1086, "totalEnergy": 0.000114 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.002, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0517, "peak": 0.2756, "totalEnergy": 0.000451 }, { "name": "rhythmSynth", "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "error": null } ], "findings": [] }, "iterations": [ { "index": 1, "candidate": { "track": "guitar", "value": 0.6, "label": "guitar -0.05", "claimCandidate": { "id": "set-guitar-level-0.65-to-0.60", "kind": "change_claim_candidate", "domain": "audio_mix", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.60 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.6, "delta": -0.05 }, "expectedReceipts": [ "mixer edit accepted", "candidate track matches requested intent", "candidate direction matches requested intent", "contract mixer level reflects requested value", "rendered target track metrics changed", "required instruments remain active", "required section energy floors remain active", "no clipping", "headroom guardrail is preserved", "no low-level proof window" ], "rankingHint": { "metric": "objective_mix_health_penalty", "lowerIsBetter": true, "role": "review_order_only" } } }, "claimCandidate": { "id": "set-guitar-level-0.65-to-0.60", "kind": "change_claim_candidate", "domain": "audio_mix", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.60 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.6, "delta": -0.05 }, "expectedReceipts": [ "mixer edit accepted", "candidate track matches requested intent", "candidate direction matches requested intent", "contract mixer level reflects requested value", "rendered target track metrics changed", "required instruments remain active", "required section energy floors remain active", "no clipping", "headroom guardrail is preserved", "no low-level proof window" ], "rankingHint": { "metric": "objective_mix_health_penalty", "lowerIsBetter": true, "role": "review_order_only" } }, "baselineRestoreReceipts": [ { "ok": true, "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "before": 0.65, "value": 0.65, "levels": null } ], "edit": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "before": 0.65, "value": 0.6, "levels": null }, "claimReceipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true, "evidence": { "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "error": null } }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true, "evidence": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" } }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true, "evidence": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.05, "source": "explicit_args" } }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true, "evidence": { "track": "guitar", "expectedLevel": 0.6, "observedLevel": 0.6 } }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true, "evidence": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0462, "peak": 0.252, "totalEnergy": 0.000374 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.04265, "peak": 0.23275, "totalEnergy": 0.00032 }, "deltas": { "rms": -0.00355, "peak": -0.01925, "totalEnergy": -0.000054 }, "thresholds": { "rms": 0.00001, "peak": 0.00001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } } }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "findings": [] } }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "sectionCount": 2, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } } ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ] } ] } }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true, "evidence": { "clippingWindows": [] } }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "headroomDb": 2.34, "headroomOk": true }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "headroomDb": 2.36, "headroomOk": true } ] } }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true, "evidence": { "lowLevelWindows": [] } } ], "claimVerdict": { "ok": true, "status": "supported", "classification": null, "failedReceipts": [] }, "candidateRankingMetric": 62.2099, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.2405, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.1115, "peak": 0.7747, "totalEnergy": 0.015805, "loudnessStyleLufs": -19.75, "headroomDb": 2.22, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.106, "peak": 0.7639, "totalEnergy": 0.015761, "loudnessStyleLufs": -20.18, "headroomDb": 2.34, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0055, "peak": -0.0108, "totalEnergy": -0.000044, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.43, "headroomDb": 0.12 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0031, "peak": -0.0175, "totalEnergy": -0.000044 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.34, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2921, "peak": 0.7726, "totalEnergy": 0.015827, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.38, "headroomDb": 2.24, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2904, "peak": 0.7619, "totalEnergy": 0.015761, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.43, "headroomDb": 2.36, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0017, "peak": -0.0107, "totalEnergy": -0.000066, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.05, "headroomDb": 0.12 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0517, "peak": 0.2756, "totalEnergy": 0.000451 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0477, "peak": 0.2546, "totalEnergy": 0.000385 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.004, "peak": -0.021, "totalEnergy": -0.000066 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.36, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.24, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000055, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "offline-audio-window-set", "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } }, "windowCount": 2, "passedCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "status": "passed", "windows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "bass", "active": true, "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "active": true, "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "active": true, "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.106, "peak": 0.7639, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.34, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 71.3476, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.047, "slopePenalty": 0.6222, "rolloffPenalty": 2.868, "presenceRatio": 0.0451, "presencePenalty": 0.8398, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.122, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2144, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 71.3476, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.047, "slopePenalty": 0.6222, "rolloffPenalty": 2.868, "presenceRatio": 0.0451, "presencePenalty": 0.8398, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.122, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2144, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 6, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1772, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.011746 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1014, "peak": 0.5843, "totalEnergy": 0.00364 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0113, "peak": 0.124, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } ], "error": null }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "active": true, "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.2904, "peak": 0.7619, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.36, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 52.5912, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.853, "slopePenalty": 2.135, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1713, "presenceRatio": 0.0386, "presencePenalty": 0.9117, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3252, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2985, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 52.5912, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.853, "slopePenalty": 2.135, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1713, "presenceRatio": 0.0386, "presencePenalty": 0.9117, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3252, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2985, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 7, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1638, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.010533 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1085, "peak": 0.6418, "totalEnergy": 0.00468 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0112, "peak": 0.1242, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0264, "peak": 0.1086, "totalEnergy": 0.000114 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.002, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0477, "peak": 0.2546, "totalEnergy": 0.000385 }, { "name": "rhythmSynth", "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "error": null } ], "findings": [] } }, { "index": 2, "candidate": { "track": "guitar", "value": 0.55, "label": "guitar -0.10", "claimCandidate": { "id": "set-guitar-level-0.65-to-0.55", "kind": "change_claim_candidate", "domain": "audio_mix", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.55 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.1 }, "expectedReceipts": [ "mixer edit accepted", "candidate track matches requested intent", "candidate direction matches requested intent", "contract mixer level reflects requested value", "rendered target track metrics changed", "required instruments remain active", "required section energy floors remain active", "no clipping", "headroom guardrail is preserved", "no low-level proof window" ], "rankingHint": { "metric": "objective_mix_health_penalty", "lowerIsBetter": true, "role": "review_order_only" } } }, "claimCandidate": { "id": "set-guitar-level-0.65-to-0.55", "kind": "change_claim_candidate", "domain": "audio_mix", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.55 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.1 }, "expectedReceipts": [ "mixer edit accepted", "candidate track matches requested intent", "candidate direction matches requested intent", "contract mixer level reflects requested value", "rendered target track metrics changed", "required instruments remain active", "required section energy floors remain active", "no clipping", "headroom guardrail is preserved", "no low-level proof window" ], "rankingHint": { "metric": "objective_mix_health_penalty", "lowerIsBetter": true, "role": "review_order_only" } }, "baselineRestoreReceipts": [ { "ok": true, "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "before": 0.6, "value": 0.65, "levels": null } ], "edit": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "before": 0.65, "value": 0.55, "levels": null }, "claimReceipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true, "evidence": { "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "error": null } }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true, "evidence": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" } }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true, "evidence": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.1, "source": "explicit_args" } }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true, "evidence": { "track": "guitar", "expectedLevel": 0.55, "observedLevel": 0.55 } }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true, "evidence": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0462, "peak": 0.252, "totalEnergy": 0.000374 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0391, "peak": 0.21335, "totalEnergy": 0.000268 }, "deltas": { "rms": -0.0071, "peak": -0.03865, "totalEnergy": -0.000106 }, "thresholds": { "rms": 0.00001, "peak": 0.00001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } } }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "findings": [] } }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "sectionCount": 2, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0345, "peak": 0.1933, "totalEnergy": 0.000214 } } ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ] } ] } }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true, "evidence": { "clippingWindows": [] } }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "headroomDb": 2.47, "headroomOk": true }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "headroomDb": 2.49, "headroomOk": true } ] } }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true, "evidence": { "lowLevelWindows": [] } } ], "claimVerdict": { "ok": true, "status": "supported", "classification": null, "failedReceipts": [] }, "candidateRankingMetric": 62.73524999999999, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.5111, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.1115, "peak": 0.7747, "totalEnergy": 0.015805, "loudnessStyleLufs": -19.75, "headroomDb": 2.22, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.1004, "peak": 0.7527, "totalEnergy": 0.015721, "loudnessStyleLufs": -20.66, "headroomDb": 2.47, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0111, "peak": -0.022, "totalEnergy": -0.000084, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.91, "headroomDb": 0.25 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0345, "peak": 0.1933, "totalEnergy": 0.000214 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0062, "peak": -0.0351, "totalEnergy": -0.000084 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0345, "peak": 0.1933, "totalEnergy": 0.000214 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.47, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2921, "peak": 0.7726, "totalEnergy": 0.015827, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.38, "headroomDb": 2.24, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2888, "peak": 0.7508, "totalEnergy": 0.015699, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.48, "headroomDb": 2.49, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0033, "peak": -0.0218, "totalEnergy": -0.000128, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.1, "headroomDb": 0.25 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0517, "peak": 0.2756, "totalEnergy": 0.000451 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0437, "peak": 0.2334, "totalEnergy": 0.000323 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.008, "peak": -0.0422, "totalEnergy": -0.000128 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.49, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.51, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000106, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "offline-audio-window-set", "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } }, "windowCount": 2, "passedCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "status": "passed", "windows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "bass", "active": true, "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "active": true, "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "active": true, "rms": 0.0345, "peak": 0.1933, "totalEnergy": 0.000214 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.1004, "peak": 0.7527, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.47, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 71.6643, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.095, "slopePenalty": 0.688, "rolloffPenalty": 2.8906, "presenceRatio": 0.0452, "presencePenalty": 0.8387, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.119, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2132, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 71.6643, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.095, "slopePenalty": 0.688, "rolloffPenalty": 2.8906, "presenceRatio": 0.0452, "presencePenalty": 0.8387, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.119, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2132, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 6, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1772, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.011746 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1014, "peak": 0.5843, "totalEnergy": 0.00364 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0113, "peak": 0.124, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0345, "peak": 0.1933, "totalEnergy": 0.000214 } ], "error": null }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "active": true, "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.2888, "peak": 0.7508, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.49, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 52.784, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.874, "slopePenalty": 2.1861, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1735, "presenceRatio": 0.0387, "presencePenalty": 0.9106, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3219, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2963, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 52.784, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.874, "slopePenalty": 2.1861, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1735, "presenceRatio": 0.0387, "presencePenalty": 0.9106, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3219, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2963, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 7, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1638, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.010533 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1085, "peak": 0.6418, "totalEnergy": 0.00468 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0112, "peak": 0.1242, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0264, "peak": 0.1086, "totalEnergy": 0.000114 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.002, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0437, "peak": 0.2334, "totalEnergy": 0.000323 }, { "name": "rhythmSynth", "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "error": null } ], "findings": [] } }, { "index": 3, "candidate": { "track": "guitar", "value": 0.47000000000000003, "label": "guitar -0.18", "claimCandidate": { "id": "set-guitar-level-0.65-to-0.47", "kind": "change_claim_candidate", "domain": "audio_mix", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.47 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.47000000000000003, "delta": -0.18 }, "expectedReceipts": [ "mixer edit accepted", "candidate track matches requested intent", "candidate direction matches requested intent", "contract mixer level reflects requested value", "rendered target track metrics changed", "required instruments remain active", "required section energy floors remain active", "no clipping", "headroom guardrail is preserved", "no low-level proof window" ], "rankingHint": { "metric": "objective_mix_health_penalty", "lowerIsBetter": true, "role": "review_order_only" } } }, "claimCandidate": { "id": "set-guitar-level-0.65-to-0.47", "kind": "change_claim_candidate", "domain": "audio_mix", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.47 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.47000000000000003, "delta": -0.18 }, "expectedReceipts": [ "mixer edit accepted", "candidate track matches requested intent", "candidate direction matches requested intent", "contract mixer level reflects requested value", "rendered target track metrics changed", "required instruments remain active", "required section energy floors remain active", "no clipping", "headroom guardrail is preserved", "no low-level proof window" ], "rankingHint": { "metric": "objective_mix_health_penalty", "lowerIsBetter": true, "role": "review_order_only" } }, "baselineRestoreReceipts": [ { "ok": true, "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "before": 0.55, "value": 0.65, "levels": null } ], "edit": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "before": 0.65, "value": 0.47000000000000003, "levels": null }, "claimReceipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true, "evidence": { "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "error": null } }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true, "evidence": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" } }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true, "evidence": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.18, "source": "explicit_args" } }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true, "evidence": { "track": "guitar", "expectedLevel": 0.47000000000000003, "observedLevel": 0.47 } }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true, "evidence": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0462, "peak": 0.252, "totalEnergy": 0.000374 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.03345, "peak": 0.1823, "totalEnergy": 0.000196 }, "deltas": { "rms": -0.01275, "peak": -0.0697, "totalEnergy": -0.000178 }, "thresholds": { "rms": 0.00001, "peak": 0.00001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } } }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "findings": [] } }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "sectionCount": 2, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0295, "peak": 0.1652, "totalEnergy": 0.000156 } } ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ] } ] } }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true, "evidence": { "clippingWindows": [] } }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "headroomDb": 2.69, "headroomOk": true }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "headroomDb": 2.65, "headroomOk": true } ] } }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true, "evidence": { "lowLevelWindows": [] } } ], "claimVerdict": { "ok": true, "status": "supported", "classification": null, "failedReceipts": [] }, "candidateRankingMetric": 63.672599999999996, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.9518, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.1115, "peak": 0.7747, "totalEnergy": 0.015805, "loudnessStyleLufs": -19.75, "headroomDb": 2.22, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0913, "peak": 0.7334, "totalEnergy": 0.015663, "loudnessStyleLufs": -21.48, "headroomDb": 2.69, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0202, "peak": -0.0413, "totalEnergy": -0.000142, "loudnessStyleLufs": -1.73, "headroomDb": 0.47 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0295, "peak": 0.1652, "totalEnergy": 0.000156 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0112, "peak": -0.0632, "totalEnergy": -0.000142 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0295, "peak": 0.1652, "totalEnergy": 0.000156 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.69, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2921, "peak": 0.7726, "totalEnergy": 0.015827, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.38, "headroomDb": 2.24, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2863, "peak": 0.7371, "totalEnergy": 0.015612, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.55, "headroomDb": 2.65, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0058, "peak": -0.0355, "totalEnergy": -0.000215, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.17, "headroomDb": 0.41 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0517, "peak": 0.2756, "totalEnergy": 0.000451 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0374, "peak": 0.1994, "totalEnergy": 0.000236 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0143, "peak": -0.0762, "totalEnergy": -0.000215 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.65, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.95, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000179, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "offline-audio-window-set", "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } }, "windowCount": 2, "passedCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "status": "passed", "windows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "bass", "active": true, "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "active": true, "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "active": true, "rms": 0.0295, "peak": 0.1652, "totalEnergy": 0.000156 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.0913, "peak": 0.7334, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.69, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 72.2397, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.18, "slopePenalty": 0.8101, "rolloffPenalty": 2.93, "presenceRatio": 0.0454, "presencePenalty": 0.8365, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.113, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2113, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 72.2397, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.18, "slopePenalty": 0.8101, "rolloffPenalty": 2.93, "presenceRatio": 0.0454, "presencePenalty": 0.8365, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.113, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2113, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 6, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1772, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.011746 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1014, "peak": 0.5843, "totalEnergy": 0.00364 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0113, "peak": 0.124, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0295, "peak": 0.1652, "totalEnergy": 0.000156 } ], "error": null }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "active": true, "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.2863, "peak": 0.7371, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.65, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 53.2019, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.914, "slopePenalty": 2.2864, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1735, "presenceRatio": 0.0386, "presencePenalty": 0.9117, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3252, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2932, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 53.2019, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.914, "slopePenalty": 2.2864, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1735, "presenceRatio": 0.0386, "presencePenalty": 0.9117, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3252, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2932, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 7, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1638, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.010533 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1085, "peak": 0.6418, "totalEnergy": 0.00468 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0112, "peak": 0.1242, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0264, "peak": 0.1086, "totalEnergy": 0.000114 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.002, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0374, "peak": 0.1994, "totalEnergy": 0.000236 }, { "name": "rhythmSynth", "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "error": null } ], "findings": [] } } ], "best": { "index": 1, "candidate": { "track": "guitar", "value": 0.6, "label": "guitar -0.05", "claimCandidate": { "id": "set-guitar-level-0.65-to-0.60", "kind": "change_claim_candidate", "domain": "audio_mix", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.60 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.6, "delta": -0.05 }, "expectedReceipts": [ "mixer edit accepted", "candidate track matches requested intent", "candidate direction matches requested intent", "contract mixer level reflects requested value", "rendered target track metrics changed", "required instruments remain active", "required section energy floors remain active", "no clipping", "headroom guardrail is preserved", "no low-level proof window" ], "rankingHint": { "metric": "objective_mix_health_penalty", "lowerIsBetter": true, "role": "review_order_only" } } }, "claimCandidate": { "id": "set-guitar-level-0.65-to-0.60", "kind": "change_claim_candidate", "domain": "audio_mix", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.60 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.6, "delta": -0.05 }, "expectedReceipts": [ "mixer edit accepted", "candidate track matches requested intent", "candidate direction matches requested intent", "contract mixer level reflects requested value", "rendered target track metrics changed", "required instruments remain active", "required section energy floors remain active", "no clipping", "headroom guardrail is preserved", "no low-level proof window" ], "rankingHint": { "metric": "objective_mix_health_penalty", "lowerIsBetter": true, "role": "review_order_only" } }, "baselineRestoreReceipts": [ { "ok": true, "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "before": 0.65, "value": 0.65, "levels": null } ], "edit": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "before": 0.65, "value": 0.6, "levels": null }, "claimReceipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true, "evidence": { "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "error": null } }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true, "evidence": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" } }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true, "evidence": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.05, "source": "explicit_args" } }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true, "evidence": { "track": "guitar", "expectedLevel": 0.6, "observedLevel": 0.6 } }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true, "evidence": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0462, "peak": 0.252, "totalEnergy": 0.000374 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.04265, "peak": 0.23275, "totalEnergy": 0.00032 }, "deltas": { "rms": -0.00355, "peak": -0.01925, "totalEnergy": -0.000054 }, "thresholds": { "rms": 0.00001, "peak": 0.00001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } } }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "findings": [] } }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "sectionCount": 2, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } } ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ] } ] } }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true, "evidence": { "clippingWindows": [] } }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "headroomDb": 2.34, "headroomOk": true }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "headroomDb": 2.36, "headroomOk": true } ] } }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true, "evidence": { "lowLevelWindows": [] } } ], "claimVerdict": { "ok": true, "status": "supported", "classification": null, "failedReceipts": [] }, "candidateRankingMetric": 62.2099, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.2405, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.1115, "peak": 0.7747, "totalEnergy": 0.015805, "loudnessStyleLufs": -19.75, "headroomDb": 2.22, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.106, "peak": 0.7639, "totalEnergy": 0.015761, "loudnessStyleLufs": -20.18, "headroomDb": 2.34, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0055, "peak": -0.0108, "totalEnergy": -0.000044, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.43, "headroomDb": 0.12 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0031, "peak": -0.0175, "totalEnergy": -0.000044 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.34, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2921, "peak": 0.7726, "totalEnergy": 0.015827, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.38, "headroomDb": 2.24, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2904, "peak": 0.7619, "totalEnergy": 0.015761, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.43, "headroomDb": 2.36, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0017, "peak": -0.0107, "totalEnergy": -0.000066, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.05, "headroomDb": 0.12 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0517, "peak": 0.2756, "totalEnergy": 0.000451 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0477, "peak": 0.2546, "totalEnergy": 0.000385 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.004, "peak": -0.021, "totalEnergy": -0.000066 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.36, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.24, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000055, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "offline-audio-window-set", "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } }, "windowCount": 2, "passedCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "status": "passed", "windows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "bass", "active": true, "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "active": true, "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "active": true, "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.106, "peak": 0.7639, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.34, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 71.3476, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.047, "slopePenalty": 0.6222, "rolloffPenalty": 2.868, "presenceRatio": 0.0451, "presencePenalty": 0.8398, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.122, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2144, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 71.3476, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.047, "slopePenalty": 0.6222, "rolloffPenalty": 2.868, "presenceRatio": 0.0451, "presencePenalty": 0.8398, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.122, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2144, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 6, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1772, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.011746 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1014, "peak": 0.5843, "totalEnergy": 0.00364 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0113, "peak": 0.124, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } ], "error": null }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "active": true, "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.2904, "peak": 0.7619, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.36, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 52.5912, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.853, "slopePenalty": 2.135, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1713, "presenceRatio": 0.0386, "presencePenalty": 0.9117, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3252, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2985, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 52.5912, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.853, "slopePenalty": 2.135, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1713, "presenceRatio": 0.0386, "presencePenalty": 0.9117, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3252, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2985, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 7, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1638, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.010533 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1085, "peak": 0.6418, "totalEnergy": 0.00468 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0112, "peak": 0.1242, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0264, "peak": 0.1086, "totalEnergy": 0.000114 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.002, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0477, "peak": 0.2546, "totalEnergy": 0.000385 }, { "name": "rhythmSynth", "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "error": null } ], "findings": [] } }, "bestClaimCandidate": { "id": "set-guitar-level-0.65-to-0.60", "kind": "change_claim_candidate", "domain": "audio_mix", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.60 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.6, "delta": -0.05 }, "expectedReceipts": [ "mixer edit accepted", "candidate track matches requested intent", "candidate direction matches requested intent", "contract mixer level reflects requested value", "rendered target track metrics changed", "required instruments remain active", "required section energy floors remain active", "no clipping", "headroom guardrail is preserved", "no low-level proof window" ], "rankingHint": { "metric": "objective_mix_health_penalty", "lowerIsBetter": true, "role": "review_order_only" } }, "humanReviewPacket": { "version": "neon-step-sequencer.human-review-packet.v1", "kind": "human_review_packet", "domain": "audio_mix", "status": "candidate_ready_for_listening_review", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "proofBoundary": "Objective receipts support or reject candidate change claims; musical taste still requires listening review.", "requestedIntent": "turn the guitar part down a little", "target": { "routeState": { "proofKind": "neon-route-state", "route": "/games/drum-sequencer", "mode": "song", "selectedSong": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)", "selectedPartIndex": 0 }, "selectedSong": { "proofKind": "neon-selected-song", "selectedSong": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)", "partCount": 9, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "description": "Humanized imported-tab mix with softer vocal formants, fuller bass harmonics, darker pads, and a deeper shared room/plate space.", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 }, "proofWindows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "bars": 1, "seed": "riddle-sequencer-bed", "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "bars": 3, "seed": "riddle-sequencer-vocal-melody", "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ] } ], "eqSettings": { "kick": [ 2.2, -0.8, -3.2, -4.5, -5.5, -5, 0.8, 0 ], "snare": [ -6, -2.5, 1.4, -3, -0.6, 1.4, 0.4, -1.8 ], "hat": [ -12, -12, -12, -10, -7, -2.5, -2.2, -1.1 ], "clap": [ -12, -8, -4, -1.5, 0.8, 0, -1, -2 ], "rim": [ -12, -8, -3.5, -1.2, 0, -0.5, -1.2, -2 ], "bass": [ -1.2, 2.8, -1.4, -4.8, -6, -8, -10, -10 ], "chord": [ -8, -2.8, -4.8, -0.8, -1, -2.8, -4.8, -6.5 ], "guitar": [ -8, -4.8, -3.4, -2.2, 1.2, 1.4, 0.2, -1.8 ], "rhythmSynth": [ -10, -6, -3.8, -1.6, 0.8, 1.8, 0, -2.8 ] }, "mixLanes": { "kick": "Sub thump around 60 Hz with most low-mid box removed.", "bass": "Bass foundation around 80-160 Hz with more 120 Hz body for small speakers.", "snare": "Backbeat body near 250 Hz with controlled upper presence.", "hat": "Soft high pulse, trimmed in brittle 4-8 kHz bands.", "chord": "Darker pad bed with more room depth and less plasticky top.", "guitar": "Mid/presence lane around 1-2 kHz, wider than the pad and glued into the shared music bus.", "rhythmSynth": "Vocal melody lane in the upper mids, forward enough to survive the small-speaker monitor without crowding 1 kHz." } } } }, "request": { "strategy": "mix-level-search", "focusTracks": [ "guitar" ], "claimTarget": { "targetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "direction": "down", "source": "explicit_args", "boundary": "Requested target and direction constrain objective candidate support; ranking still only orders listening review." }, "maxIterations": 3, "monitorProfile": "smallSpeaker", "restore": true, "applyBest": false, "candidateActionsAreTransient": true, "approval": null }, "recommendation": { "action": "review_before_applying_candidate", "candidate": { "index": 1, "label": "guitar -0.05", "status": "supported", "classification": null, "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.60 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.6, "delta": -0.05 }, "rankingMetric": 62.2099, "receipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true } ], "failedReceipts": [], "guardrails": { "mixerEditAccepted": true, "candidateTrackMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "candidateDirectionMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "contractLevelReflected": true, "renderedTargetMoved": true, "requiredInstrumentsPreserved": true, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "noClipping": true, "headroomPreserved": true, "noLowLevelProofWindow": true }, "targetMovement": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "deltas": { "rms": -0.00355, "peak": -0.01925, "totalEnergy": -0.000054 }, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0462, "peak": 0.252, "totalEnergy": 0.000374 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.04265, "peak": 0.23275, "totalEnergy": 0.00032 } }, "requestedIntentMatch": { "track": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" }, "direction": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.05, "source": "explicit_args" } }, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.2405, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.1115, "peak": 0.7747, "totalEnergy": 0.015805, "loudnessStyleLufs": -19.75, "headroomDb": 2.22, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.106, "peak": 0.7639, "totalEnergy": 0.015761, "loudnessStyleLufs": -20.18, "headroomDb": 2.34, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0055, "peak": -0.0108, "totalEnergy": -0.000044, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.43, "headroomDb": 0.12 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0031, "peak": -0.0175, "totalEnergy": -0.000044 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.34, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2921, "peak": 0.7726, "totalEnergy": 0.015827, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.38, "headroomDb": 2.24, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2904, "peak": 0.7619, "totalEnergy": 0.015761, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.43, "headroomDb": 2.36, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0017, "peak": -0.0107, "totalEnergy": -0.000066, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.05, "headroomDb": 0.12 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0517, "peak": 0.2756, "totalEnergy": 0.000451 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0477, "peak": 0.2546, "totalEnergy": 0.000385 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.004, "peak": -0.021, "totalEnergy": -0.000066 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.36, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.24, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000055, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "status": "passed", "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } } } }, "reason": "All objective claim receipts passed for this candidate; ranking only orders listening review." }, "supportedCandidates": [ { "index": 1, "label": "guitar -0.05", "status": "supported", "classification": null, "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.60 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.6, "delta": -0.05 }, "rankingMetric": 62.2099, "receipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true } ], "failedReceipts": [], "guardrails": { "mixerEditAccepted": true, "candidateTrackMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "candidateDirectionMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "contractLevelReflected": true, "renderedTargetMoved": true, "requiredInstrumentsPreserved": true, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "noClipping": true, "headroomPreserved": true, "noLowLevelProofWindow": true }, "targetMovement": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "deltas": { "rms": -0.00355, "peak": -0.01925, "totalEnergy": -0.000054 }, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0462, "peak": 0.252, "totalEnergy": 0.000374 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.04265, "peak": 0.23275, "totalEnergy": 0.00032 } }, "requestedIntentMatch": { "track": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" }, "direction": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.05, "source": "explicit_args" } }, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.2405, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.1115, "peak": 0.7747, "totalEnergy": 0.015805, "loudnessStyleLufs": -19.75, "headroomDb": 2.22, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.106, "peak": 0.7639, "totalEnergy": 0.015761, "loudnessStyleLufs": -20.18, "headroomDb": 2.34, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0055, "peak": -0.0108, "totalEnergy": -0.000044, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.43, "headroomDb": 0.12 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0031, "peak": -0.0175, "totalEnergy": -0.000044 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.34, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2921, "peak": 0.7726, "totalEnergy": 0.015827, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.38, "headroomDb": 2.24, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2904, "peak": 0.7619, "totalEnergy": 0.015761, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.43, "headroomDb": 2.36, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0017, "peak": -0.0107, "totalEnergy": -0.000066, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.05, "headroomDb": 0.12 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0517, "peak": 0.2756, "totalEnergy": 0.000451 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0477, "peak": 0.2546, "totalEnergy": 0.000385 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.004, "peak": -0.021, "totalEnergy": -0.000066 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.36, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.24, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000055, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "status": "passed", "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } } } }, { "index": 2, "label": "guitar -0.10", "status": "supported", "classification": null, "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.55 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.1 }, "rankingMetric": 62.7352, "receipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true } ], "failedReceipts": [], "guardrails": { "mixerEditAccepted": true, "candidateTrackMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "candidateDirectionMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "contractLevelReflected": true, "renderedTargetMoved": true, "requiredInstrumentsPreserved": true, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "noClipping": true, "headroomPreserved": true, "noLowLevelProofWindow": true }, "targetMovement": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "deltas": { "rms": -0.0071, "peak": -0.03865, "totalEnergy": -0.000106 }, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0462, "peak": 0.252, "totalEnergy": 0.000374 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0391, "peak": 0.21335, "totalEnergy": 0.000268 } }, "requestedIntentMatch": { "track": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" }, "direction": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.1, "source": "explicit_args" } }, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.5111, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.1115, "peak": 0.7747, "totalEnergy": 0.015805, "loudnessStyleLufs": -19.75, "headroomDb": 2.22, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.1004, "peak": 0.7527, "totalEnergy": 0.015721, "loudnessStyleLufs": -20.66, "headroomDb": 2.47, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0111, "peak": -0.022, "totalEnergy": -0.000084, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.91, "headroomDb": 0.25 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0345, "peak": 0.1933, "totalEnergy": 0.000214 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0062, "peak": -0.0351, "totalEnergy": -0.000084 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0345, "peak": 0.1933, "totalEnergy": 0.000214 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.47, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2921, "peak": 0.7726, "totalEnergy": 0.015827, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.38, "headroomDb": 2.24, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2888, "peak": 0.7508, "totalEnergy": 0.015699, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.48, "headroomDb": 2.49, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0033, "peak": -0.0218, "totalEnergy": -0.000128, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.1, "headroomDb": 0.25 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0517, "peak": 0.2756, "totalEnergy": 0.000451 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0437, "peak": 0.2334, "totalEnergy": 0.000323 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.008, "peak": -0.0422, "totalEnergy": -0.000128 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.49, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.51, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000106, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "status": "passed", "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } } } }, { "index": 3, "label": "guitar -0.18", "status": "supported", "classification": null, "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.47 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.47, "delta": -0.18 }, "rankingMetric": 63.6726, "receipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true } ], "failedReceipts": [], "guardrails": { "mixerEditAccepted": true, "candidateTrackMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "candidateDirectionMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "contractLevelReflected": true, "renderedTargetMoved": true, "requiredInstrumentsPreserved": true, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "noClipping": true, "headroomPreserved": true, "noLowLevelProofWindow": true }, "targetMovement": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "deltas": { "rms": -0.01275, "peak": -0.0697, "totalEnergy": -0.000178 }, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0462, "peak": 0.252, "totalEnergy": 0.000374 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.03345, "peak": 0.1823, "totalEnergy": 0.000196 } }, "requestedIntentMatch": { "track": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" }, "direction": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.18, "source": "explicit_args" } }, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.9518, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.1115, "peak": 0.7747, "totalEnergy": 0.015805, "loudnessStyleLufs": -19.75, "headroomDb": 2.22, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0913, "peak": 0.7334, "totalEnergy": 0.015663, "loudnessStyleLufs": -21.48, "headroomDb": 2.69, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0202, "peak": -0.0413, "totalEnergy": -0.000142, "loudnessStyleLufs": -1.73, "headroomDb": 0.47 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0295, "peak": 0.1652, "totalEnergy": 0.000156 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0112, "peak": -0.0632, "totalEnergy": -0.000142 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0295, "peak": 0.1652, "totalEnergy": 0.000156 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.69, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2921, "peak": 0.7726, "totalEnergy": 0.015827, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.38, "headroomDb": 2.24, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2863, "peak": 0.7371, "totalEnergy": 0.015612, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.55, "headroomDb": 2.65, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0058, "peak": -0.0355, "totalEnergy": -0.000215, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.17, "headroomDb": 0.41 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0517, "peak": 0.2756, "totalEnergy": 0.000451 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0374, "peak": 0.1994, "totalEnergy": 0.000236 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0143, "peak": -0.0762, "totalEnergy": -0.000215 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.65, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.95, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000179, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "status": "passed", "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } } } } ], "rejectedCandidates": [], "ranking": { "metric": "guardrail_preserving_section_energy_review_order", "role": "review_order_only", "lowerIsBetter": true, "baselineCandidateRankingMetric": 61.6628, "bestCandidateRankingMetric": 62.2099, "rankingMetricDelta": -0.547, "sectionHeuristics": { "enabled": true, "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "loudnessStyle": "rms_dbfs_estimate", "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Section-energy and loudness-style metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." } }, "baseline": { "status": "passed", "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } } }, "guardrails": { "supportedClaimCandidateCount": 3, "rejectedCandidateCount": 0, "stateRestoredAfterLoop": true, "noPermanentEditUnlessApplyBest": true, "approvedCandidateApplied": null }, "listenerPrompts": [ "Does the supported candidate match the requested musical intent?", "Is the changed part better balanced in the proof window?", "Did the proof window contain the musical material being judged?", "Would another section or speaker profile change the listening decision?" ], "caveats": [ "This packet does not prove subjective mix quality.", "A supported candidate proves objective receipts and guardrails only.", "Ranking orders review; it is not a taste score.", "Section-energy and loudness-style metrics are review aids, not proof that a candidate sounds better.", "Keep or apply the candidate only after listening review." ] }, "restorationReceipt": { "name": "state_restored_after_claim_candidate_loop", "ok": true, "expectedLevels": { "guitar": 0.65 }, "observedLevels": { "guitar": 0.65 } }, "appliedCandidateReceipt": null, "classification": null, "caveats": [ "candidateRankingMetric is only a review-order hint", "sectionEnergyComparison is a loudness-style and energy-floor review aid, not a taste score", "claim verdicts come from receipts and invariants, not taste optimization", "human listening review is required before accepting any musical change", "candidate actions are transient unless applyBest is true" ] }, "return_summary": [ { "label": "ok", "path": "ok", "exists": true, "value": true }, { "label": "status", "path": "status", "exists": true, "value": "claim_candidate_supported" }, { "label": "strategy", "path": "strategy", "exists": true, "value": "mix-level-search" }, { "label": "best.claimVerdict.status", "path": "best.claimVerdict.status", "exists": true, "value": "supported" }, { "label": "best.claimCandidate.action.track", "path": "best.claimCandidate.action.track", "exists": true, "value": "guitar" }, { "label": "supportedClaimCandidateCount", "path": "supportedClaimCandidateCount", "exists": true, "value": 3 }, { "label": "humanReviewPacket.status", "path": "humanReviewPacket.status", "exists": true, "value": "candidate_ready_for_listening_review" }, { "label": "humanReviewPacket.recommendation.candidate.action.track", "path": "humanReviewPacket.recommendation.candidate.action.track", "exists": true, "value": "guitar" }, { "label": "humanReviewPacket.ranking.role", "path": "humanReviewPacket.ranking.role", "exists": true, "value": "review_order_only" }, { "label": "humanReviewPacket.ranking.metric", "path": "humanReviewPacket.ranking.metric", "exists": true, "value": "guardrail_preserving_section_energy_review_order" }, { "label": "humanReviewPacket.recommendation.candidate.sectionEnergyComparison.requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved", "path": "humanReviewPacket.recommendation.candidate.sectionEnergyComparison.requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved", "exists": true, "value": true }, { "label": "humanReviewPacket.recommendation.candidate.sectionEnergyComparison.guardrailsPreserved", "path": "humanReviewPacket.recommendation.candidate.sectionEnergyComparison.guardrailsPreserved", "exists": true, "value": true }, { "label": "requestConstraints.targetTracks", "path": "requestConstraints.targetTracks", "exists": true, "value": [ "guitar" ] }, { "label": "requestConstraints.direction", "path": "requestConstraints.direction", "exists": true, "value": "down" }, { "label": "humanReviewPacket.request.claimTarget.targetTracks", "path": "humanReviewPacket.request.claimTarget.targetTracks", "exists": true, "value": [ "guitar" ] }, { "label": "humanReviewPacket.request.claimTarget.direction", "path": "humanReviewPacket.request.claimTarget.direction", "exists": true, "value": "down" }, { "label": "humanReviewPacket.guardrails.supportedClaimCandidateCount", "path": "humanReviewPacket.guardrails.supportedClaimCandidateCount", "exists": true, "value": 3 }, { "label": "humanReviewPacket.guardrails.rejectedCandidateCount", "path": "humanReviewPacket.guardrails.rejectedCandidateCount", "exists": true, "value": 0 } ] } ], "window_eval_total": 1, "window_eval_stored_total": 1, "window_eval_captured_total": 1, "window_eval_truncated": false, "window_eval": [ { "ordinal": 0, "ok": true, "script_length": 236, "return_captured": true, "return_stored_to": "__neonMixProof.contract", "reason": null, "returned": { "available": true, "diagnostic": { "version": "neon-step-sequencer.capture-diagnostic.v1", "target": "neon-step-sequencer", "capturedAt": "2026-05-25T06:00:04.808Z", "routeState": { "proofKind": "neon-route-state", "route": "/games/drum-sequencer", "mode": "song", "selectedSong": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)", "selectedPartIndex": 0 }, "selectedSong": { "proofKind": "neon-selected-song", "selectedSong": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)", "partCount": 9, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "description": "Humanized imported-tab mix with softer vocal formants, fuller bass harmonics, darker pads, and a deeper shared room/plate space.", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 }, "proofWindows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "bars": 1, "seed": "riddle-sequencer-bed", "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "bars": 3, "seed": "riddle-sequencer-vocal-melody", "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ] } ], "eqSettings": { "kick": [ 2.2, -0.8, -3.2, -4.5, -5.5, -5, 0.8, 0 ], "snare": [ -6, -2.5, 1.4, -3, -0.6, 1.4, 0.4, -1.8 ], "hat": [ -12, -12, -12, -10, -7, -2.5, -2.2, -1.1 ], "clap": [ -12, -8, -4, -1.5, 0.8, 0, -1, -2 ], "rim": [ -12, -8, -3.5, -1.2, 0, -0.5, -1.2, -2 ], "bass": [ -1.2, 2.8, -1.4, -4.8, -6, -8, -10, -10 ], "chord": [ -8, -2.8, -4.8, -0.8, -1, -2.8, -4.8, -6.5 ], "guitar": [ -8, -4.8, -3.4, -2.2, 1.2, 1.4, 0.2, -1.8 ], "rhythmSynth": [ -10, -6, -3.8, -1.6, 0.8, 1.8, 0, -2.8 ] }, "mixLanes": { "kick": "Sub thump around 60 Hz with most low-mid box removed.", "bass": "Bass foundation around 80-160 Hz with more 120 Hz body for small speakers.", "snare": "Backbeat body near 250 Hz with controlled upper presence.", "hat": "Soft high pulse, trimmed in brittle 4-8 kHz bands.", "chord": "Darker pad bed with more room depth and less plasticky top.", "guitar": "Mid/presence lane around 1-2 kHz, wider than the pad and glued into the shared music bus.", "rhythmSynth": "Vocal melody lane in the upper mids, forward enough to survive the small-speaker monitor without crowding 1 kHz." } } }, "mixerState": { "proofKind": "neon-mixer-state", "levels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 }, "eqSettings": { "kick": [ 2.2, -0.8, -3.2, -4.5, -5.5, -5, 0.8, 0 ], "snare": [ -6, -2.5, 1.4, -3, -0.6, 1.4, 0.4, -1.8 ], "hat": [ -12, -12, -12, -10, -7, -2.5, -2.2, -1.1 ], "clap": [ -12, -8, -4, -1.5, 0.8, 0, -1, -2 ], "rim": [ -12, -8, -3.5, -1.2, 0, -0.5, -1.2, -2 ], "bass": [ -1.2, 2.8, -1.4, -4.8, -6, -8, -10, -10 ], "chord": [ -8, -2.8, -4.8, -0.8, -1, -2.8, -4.8, -6.5 ], "guitar": [ -8, -4.8, -3.4, -2.2, 1.2, 1.4, 0.2, -1.8 ], "rhythmSynth": [ -10, -6, -3.8, -1.6, 0.8, 1.8, 0, -2.8 ] }, "panSettings": { "kick": 0, "snare": 0.03, "hat": 0.24, "clap": -0.18, "rim": 0.16, "bass": -0.01, "chord": -0.22, "guitar": 0.26, "rhythmSynth": 0.02 }, "delaySettings": { "chord": { "enabled": true, "time": 0.29, "feedback": 0.12, "mix": 0.1 }, "guitar": { "enabled": true, "time": 0.19, "feedback": 0.16, "mix": 0.11 }, "rhythmSynth": { "enabled": true, "time": 0.24, "feedback": 0.1, "mix": 0.07 } }, "synthParams": { "bass": { "waveform": "triangle", "filterCutoff": 220, "filterQ": 0.92, "attack": 0.035, "release": 0.56, "peakGain": 0.25, "sustainGain": 0.14, "secondaryWaveform": "sawtooth", "secondaryGain": 0.22, "secondaryDetune": -5, "filterEnvStart": 640, "filterEnvDecay": 0.23, "decay": 0.26, "subGain": 0.08, "drive": 0.68 }, "chord": { "style": "dark", "oscType": "triangle", "oscType2": "sine", "filterCutoff": 500, "filterSettleRatio": 0.86, "attack": 0.48, "release": 1.9, "gain": 0.22, "noteAttack": 0.06, "noteDecay": 0.22, "noteSustain": 0.42, "noteRelease": 0.7, "noteFilterCutoff": 1350, "noteFilterEndRatio": 0.24, "noteDetuneRange": 3.6 }, "guitar": { "oscType": "sawtooth", "lowpassFreq": 2600, "wahFreqStart": 560, "wahFreqPeak": 1180, "wahFreqEnd": 700, "peakGain": 0.104, "release": 0.56, "detuneRange": 5, "wahQ": 0.68, "stringDamping": 0.5, "attack": 0.015, "spreadRatio": 0.2, "pickNoiseGain": 0.045, "pickFilterFreq": 2500, "pickDecay": 0.019, "bodyFreq": 620, "bodyQ": 1.15, "bodyGain": 2.8 }, "rhythmSynth": { "oscType": "triangle", "filterCutoff": 1860, "filterQ": 0.72, "attack": 0.038, "peakGain": 0.112, "decay": 0.22, "sustainGain": 0.064, "release": 0.66, "source": "voice_oohs", "oscType2": "sine", "osc2Gain": 0.22, "osc2Detune": 3, "transpose": 12, "filterEnvStart": 2650, "filterEnvDecay": 0.2, "highpassFreq": 260, "drive": 0.12, "vibratoDepth": 8, "vibratoRate": 4.7, "vibratoDelay": 0.11, "formantFreq": 1120, "formantQ": 0.85, "formantGain": 0.8 }, "humanize": { "enabled": true, "seed": "monkberry-humanized-v1", "timingMs": 8, "velocity": 0.075, "swing": 0.055, "instrumentDelayMs": { "kick": 0, "snare": 7, "hat": 3, "clap": 10, "rim": 6, "bass": 2, "chord": 5, "guitar": 9, "rhythmSynth": 12 } }, "drums": { "kick": { "freqStart": 118, "freqEnd": 43, "pitchDecay": 0.17, "decay": 0.28, "gain": 0.96, "clickGain": 0.018, "clickDecay": 0.012, "drive": 0.9 }, "snare": { "noiseFilterFreq": 520, "noiseGain": 0.18, "noiseDecay": 0.22, "toneFreq": 190, "toneGain": 0.25, "toneDecay": 0.22 }, "hat": { "filterFreq": 6100, "gain": 0.115, "decay": 0.105 }, "clap": { "filterFreq": 1120, "gain": 0.16, "burstDecay": 0.095 }, "rim": { "noiseFilterFreq": 1800, "noiseGain": 0.09, "noiseDecay": 0.075, "toneFreq": 410, "toneGain": 0.06, "toneDecay": 0.08 } }, "ambience": { "enabled": true, "room": { "enabled": true, "seconds": 0.46, "decay": 2.25, "gain": 0.11, "preDelay": 0.014, "highpass": 220, "lowpass": 5400 }, "plate": { "enabled": true, "seconds": 1.05, "decay": 2.85, "gain": 0.08, "preDelay": 0.038, "highpass": 560, "lowpass": 4600 }, "sends": { "kick": { "room": 0.008 }, "snare": { "room": 0.16, "plate": 0.055 }, "hat": { "room": 0.026 }, "clap": { "room": 0.12, "plate": 0.045 }, "rim": { "room": 0.08 }, "bass": { "room": 0.016 }, "chord": { "room": 0.11, "plate": 0.085 }, "guitar": { "room": 0.115, "plate": 0.09 }, "rhythmSynth": { "room": 0.06, "plate": 0.13 } } }, "groupBuses": { "music": { "enabled": true, "gain": 1, "drive": 1.12, "highpass": 170, "lowpass": 6200, "lowshelfFreq": 240, "lowshelfGain": -0.4, "presenceFreq": 2150, "presenceQ": 0.95, "presenceGain": -0.7, "highshelfFreq": 4700, "highshelfGain": -1.1, "compressor": { "threshold": -22, "ratio": 2.4, "attack": 0.014, "release": 0.26, "knee": 20 } } } }, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 }, "trackLabels": { "chord": "Pad / Keys", "rhythmSynth": "Vocal Melody" }, "trackRoles": { "kick": "Drum low end", "snare": "Backbeat", "hat": "Pulse", "clap": "Cymbal accents", "rim": "Toms", "bass": "With-vocal bass foundation", "chord": "Reduced harmony bed", "guitar": "Lead and rhythm guitars", "rhythmSynth": "With-vocal top line" }, "mixLanes": { "kick": "Sub thump around 60 Hz with most low-mid box removed.", "bass": "Bass foundation around 80-160 Hz with more 120 Hz body for small speakers.", "snare": "Backbeat body near 250 Hz with controlled upper presence.", "hat": "Soft high pulse, trimmed in brittle 4-8 kHz bands.", "chord": "Darker pad bed with more room depth and less plasticky top.", "guitar": "Mid/presence lane around 1-2 kHz, wider than the pad and glued into the shared music bus.", "rhythmSynth": "Vocal melody lane in the upper mids, forward enough to survive the small-speaker monitor without crowding 1 kHz." }, "proofWindows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "bars": 1, "seed": "riddle-sequencer-bed", "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "bars": 3, "seed": "riddle-sequencer-vocal-melody", "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ] } ] } }, "sourceState": { "proofKind": "neon-source-state", "drums": { "source": "samples", "status": "idle", "loadedTrackCount": 0, "loadedSampleCount": 0, "loadedSampleNames": [], "library": { "name": "LM-2 sampled drum machine", "license": "Public domain sample pack", "trackCount": 5, "sampleCount": 8, "sampleNames": [ "kick", "kick-alt", "snare-m", "hhclosed-short", "hhclosed", "hhclosed-long", "clap", "stick-m" ] } }, "bass": { "source": "hybrid", "status": "idle", "loadedSampleCount": 0, "library": { "name": "tonejs-instruments bass-electric", "license": "CC BY 3.0", "sampleCount": 6 } }, "chord": { "source": "hybrid", "status": "idle", "loadedSampleCount": 0, "library": { "name": "tonejs-instruments piano", "license": "CC BY 3.0", "sampleCount": 7 } }, "guitar": { "source": "hybrid", "status": "idle", "loadedSampleCount": 0, "library": { "name": "tonejs-instruments guitar-electric", "license": "CC BY 3.0", "sampleCount": 9 } }, "vocal": { "source": "voice_oohs", "status": "idle", "loadedSampleCount": 0, "library": { "name": "FluidR3 General MIDI SoundFont", "license": "CC BY 3.0", "instruments": [ "voice_oohs", "choir_aahs", "lead_6_voice", "synth_choir" ] } } }, "playbackState": { "proofKind": "neon-playback-state", "isPlaying": false, "selectedPartIndex": 0, "arrangement": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 ], "trainer": { "selectedInstrument": "bass", "partIndex": 0, "partLabel": "A", "sequencePosition": 0, "playbackPartIndex": null, "playbackStepCount": 256, "currentStep": 0, "eventCount": 68, "visibleEventCount": 9, "pianoKeyCount": 10, "windowBars": 2, "backingMode": "full" } }, "state": { "route": "/games/drum-sequencer", "mode": "song", "isPlaying": false, "selectedSong": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)", "selectedPartIndex": 0, "partCount": 9, "arrangement": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 ], "trainer": { "selectedInstrument": "bass", "partIndex": 0, "partLabel": "A", "sequencePosition": 0, "playbackPartIndex": null, "playbackStepCount": 256, "currentStep": 0, "eventCount": 68, "visibleEventCount": 9, "pianoKeyCount": 10, "windowBars": 2, "backingMode": "full" }, "profile": { "tempo": 98, "barCount": 16, "enabled": { "bass": true, "chord": true, "guitar": true, "rhythmSynth": true }, "labels": { "rhythmSynth": "Vocal Melody", "chord": "Pad / Keys" }, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "description": "Humanized imported-tab mix with softer vocal formants, fuller bass harmonics, darker pads, and a deeper shared room/plate space.", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 }, "proofWindows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "bars": 1, "seed": "riddle-sequencer-bed", "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "bars": 3, "seed": "riddle-sequencer-vocal-melody", "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ] } ], "eqSettings": { "kick": [ 2.2, -0.8, -3.2, -4.5, -5.5, -5, 0.8, 0 ], "snare": [ -6, -2.5, 1.4, -3, -0.6, 1.4, 0.4, -1.8 ], "hat": [ -12, -12, -12, -10, -7, -2.5, -2.2, -1.1 ], "clap": [ -12, -8, -4, -1.5, 0.8, 0, -1, -2 ], "rim": [ -12, -8, -3.5, -1.2, 0, -0.5, -1.2, -2 ], "bass": [ -1.2, 2.8, -1.4, -4.8, -6, -8, -10, -10 ], "chord": [ -8, -2.8, -4.8, -0.8, -1, -2.8, -4.8, -6.5 ], "guitar": [ -8, -4.8, -3.4, -2.2, 1.2, 1.4, 0.2, -1.8 ], "rhythmSynth": [ -10, -6, -3.8, -1.6, 0.8, 1.8, 0, -2.8 ] }, "mixLanes": { "kick": "Sub thump around 60 Hz with most low-mid box removed.", "bass": "Bass foundation around 80-160 Hz with more 120 Hz body for small speakers.", "snare": "Backbeat body near 250 Hz with controlled upper presence.", "hat": "Soft high pulse, trimmed in brittle 4-8 kHz bands.", "chord": "Darker pad bed with more room depth and less plasticky top.", "guitar": "Mid/presence lane around 1-2 kHz, wider than the pad and glued into the shared music bus.", "rhythmSynth": "Vocal melody lane in the upper mids, forward enough to survive the small-speaker monitor without crowding 1 kHz." } }, "trackRoles": { "kick": "Drum low end", "snare": "Backbeat", "hat": "Pulse", "clap": "Cymbal accents", "rim": "Toms", "bass": "With-vocal bass foundation", "chord": "Reduced harmony bed", "guitar": "Lead and rhythm guitars", "rhythmSynth": "With-vocal top line" }, "activeCounts": { "drums": 208, "bass": 68, "chord": 84, "guitar": 639, "rhythmSynth": 77 }, "activeRows": { "drums": 3, "bass": 6, "chord": 10, "guitar": 16 }, "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 }, "eqSettings": { "kick": [ 2.2, -0.8, -3.2, -4.5, -5.5, -5, 0.8, 0 ], "snare": [ -6, -2.5, 1.4, -3, -0.6, 1.4, 0.4, -1.8 ], "hat": [ -12, -12, -12, -10, -7, -2.5, -2.2, -1.1 ], "clap": [ -12, -8, -4, -1.5, 0.8, 0, -1, -2 ], "rim": [ -12, -8, -3.5, -1.2, 0, -0.5, -1.2, -2 ], "bass": [ -1.2, 2.8, -1.4, -4.8, -6, -8, -10, -10 ], "chord": [ -8, -2.8, -4.8, -0.8, -1, -2.8, -4.8, -6.5 ], "guitar": [ -8, -4.8, -3.4, -2.2, 1.2, 1.4, 0.2, -1.8 ], "rhythmSynth": [ -10, -6, -3.8, -1.6, 0.8, 1.8, 0, -2.8 ] }, "panSettings": { "kick": 0, "snare": 0.03, "hat": 0.24, "clap": -0.18, "rim": 0.16, "bass": -0.01, "chord": -0.22, "guitar": 0.26, "rhythmSynth": 0.02 }, "delaySettings": { "chord": { "enabled": true, "time": 0.29, "feedback": 0.12, "mix": 0.1 }, "guitar": { "enabled": true, "time": 0.19, "feedback": 0.16, "mix": 0.11 }, "rhythmSynth": { "enabled": true, "time": 0.24, "feedback": 0.1, "mix": 0.07 } }, "synthParams": { "bass": { "waveform": "triangle", "filterCutoff": 220, "filterQ": 0.92, "attack": 0.035, "release": 0.56, "peakGain": 0.25, "sustainGain": 0.14, "secondaryWaveform": "sawtooth", "secondaryGain": 0.22, "secondaryDetune": -5, "filterEnvStart": 640, "filterEnvDecay": 0.23, "decay": 0.26, "subGain": 0.08, "drive": 0.68 }, "chord": { "style": "dark", "oscType": "triangle", "oscType2": "sine", "filterCutoff": 500, "filterSettleRatio": 0.86, "attack": 0.48, "release": 1.9, "gain": 0.22, "noteAttack": 0.06, "noteDecay": 0.22, "noteSustain": 0.42, "noteRelease": 0.7, "noteFilterCutoff": 1350, "noteFilterEndRatio": 0.24, "noteDetuneRange": 3.6 }, "guitar": { "oscType": "sawtooth", "lowpassFreq": 2600, "wahFreqStart": 560, "wahFreqPeak": 1180, "wahFreqEnd": 700, "peakGain": 0.104, "release": 0.56, "detuneRange": 5, "wahQ": 0.68, "stringDamping": 0.5, "attack": 0.015, "spreadRatio": 0.2, "pickNoiseGain": 0.045, "pickFilterFreq": 2500, "pickDecay": 0.019, "bodyFreq": 620, "bodyQ": 1.15, "bodyGain": 2.8 }, "rhythmSynth": { "oscType": "triangle", "filterCutoff": 1860, "filterQ": 0.72, "attack": 0.038, "peakGain": 0.112, "decay": 0.22, "sustainGain": 0.064, "release": 0.66, "source": "voice_oohs", "oscType2": "sine", "osc2Gain": 0.22, "osc2Detune": 3, "transpose": 12, "filterEnvStart": 2650, "filterEnvDecay": 0.2, "highpassFreq": 260, "drive": 0.12, "vibratoDepth": 8, "vibratoRate": 4.7, "vibratoDelay": 0.11, "formantFreq": 1120, "formantQ": 0.85, "formantGain": 0.8 }, "humanize": { "enabled": true, "seed": "monkberry-humanized-v1", "timingMs": 8, "velocity": 0.075, "swing": 0.055, "instrumentDelayMs": { "kick": 0, "snare": 7, "hat": 3, "clap": 10, "rim": 6, "bass": 2, "chord": 5, "guitar": 9, "rhythmSynth": 12 } }, "drums": { "kick": { "freqStart": 118, "freqEnd": 43, "pitchDecay": 0.17, "decay": 0.28, "gain": 0.96, "clickGain": 0.018, "clickDecay": 0.012, "drive": 0.9 }, "snare": { "noiseFilterFreq": 520, "noiseGain": 0.18, "noiseDecay": 0.22, "toneFreq": 190, "toneGain": 0.25, "toneDecay": 0.22 }, "hat": { "filterFreq": 6100, "gain": 0.115, "decay": 0.105 }, "clap": { "filterFreq": 1120, "gain": 0.16, "burstDecay": 0.095 }, "rim": { "noiseFilterFreq": 1800, "noiseGain": 0.09, "noiseDecay": 0.075, "toneFreq": 410, "toneGain": 0.06, "toneDecay": 0.08 } }, "ambience": { "enabled": true, "room": { "enabled": true, "seconds": 0.46, "decay": 2.25, "gain": 0.11, "preDelay": 0.014, "highpass": 220, "lowpass": 5400 }, "plate": { "enabled": true, "seconds": 1.05, "decay": 2.85, "gain": 0.08, "preDelay": 0.038, "highpass": 560, "lowpass": 4600 }, "sends": { "kick": { "room": 0.008 }, "snare": { "room": 0.16, "plate": 0.055 }, "hat": { "room": 0.026 }, "clap": { "room": 0.12, "plate": 0.045 }, "rim": { "room": 0.08 }, "bass": { "room": 0.016 }, "chord": { "room": 0.11, "plate": 0.085 }, "guitar": { "room": 0.115, "plate": 0.09 }, "rhythmSynth": { "room": 0.06, "plate": 0.13 } } }, "groupBuses": { "music": { "enabled": true, "gain": 1, "drive": 1.12, "highpass": 170, "lowpass": 6200, "lowshelfFreq": 240, "lowshelfGain": -0.4, "presenceFreq": 2150, "presenceQ": 0.95, "presenceGain": -0.7, "highshelfFreq": 4700, "highshelfGain": -1.1, "compressor": { "threshold": -22, "ratio": 2.4, "attack": 0.014, "release": 0.26, "knee": 20 } } } } }, "supportsOfflineAudio": true } } }, "return_summary": [ { "label": "available", "path": "available", "exists": true, "value": true }, { "label": "diagnostic.selectedSong.selectedSong", "path": "diagnostic.selectedSong.selectedSong", "exists": true, "value": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)" } ] } ], "deterministic_runtime_total": 0, "deterministic_runtime_truncated": false, "deterministic_runtime": [], "set_range_value_total": 0, "set_range_value_truncated": false, "set_range_value": [], "drag_total": 0, "drag_truncated": false, "drag": [], "tap_total": 0, "tap_truncated": false, "tap": [], "tap_until_total": 0, "tap_until_tap_total": 0, "tap_until_truncated": false, "tap_until": [], "keyboard_total": 0, "keyboard_truncated": false, "keyboard": [], "canvas_signature_total": 0, "canvas_signature_truncated": false, "canvas_signature": [], "canvas_signature_stable_hash_groups": [], "clicked": [], "text_samples": [], "failed": [], "optional_failed": [] } ] }, "failed": [] } }, { "type": "route_loaded", "label": "route_loaded", "status": "passed", "evidence": { "expected_path": "/games/drum-sequencer", "observed_paths": [ "/games/drum-sequencer" ], "http_statuses": [ 200 ], "route_errors": [ null ] } }, { "type": "selector_visible", "label": "selector_visible", "status": "passed", "evidence": { "selector": ".drum-sequencer h1", "visible_counts": [ 1 ] } }, { "type": "no_horizontal_overflow", "label": "no_horizontal_overflow", "status": "passed", "evidence": { "max_overflow_px": 4, "overflow_px": [ 0 ], "bounds_overflow_px": [ 0 ], "overflow_offender_counts": [ 0 ], "viewports": [ "desktop" ] } }, { "type": "no_fatal_console_errors", "label": "no_fatal_console_errors", "status": "passed", "evidence": { "console_fatal_count": 0, "page_error_count": 0, "total_console_fatal_count": 0, "total_page_error_count": 0, "allowed_console_fatal_count": 0, "explicitly_allowed_console_fatal_count": 0, "allowed_expected_network_mock_console_count": 0, "allowed_expected_network_mock_console_events": [], "allowed_page_error_count": 0, "allowed_console_texts": [], "allowed_console_patterns": [], "allowed_page_error_texts": [], "allowed_page_error_patterns": [] } } ], "summary": "lilarcade-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search-generated-prelim-candidate passed 5 check(s) across 1 viewport(s) (desktop).", "captured_at": "2026-05-25T06:00:03.522Z", "metadata": { "pack_id": "neon_step_sequencer", "pack_public_name": "Neon Step Sequencer Pack", "evidence_role_pattern": "interaction_snapshots", "purpose": "Run a bounded loop that tests Neon mix-level change-claim candidates using the mix-level-search strategy. Generated for a narrower local preliminary loop; promotion presets still use the full profile unless explicitly overridden.", "required_receipts": [ "ratchet loop returns ok", "baseline proof-window summary is captured", "claim candidates are captured", "each candidate records claim receipts", "each candidate records section-by-section energy and loudness-style comparisons", "best supported claim candidate or human-review status is captured", "compact human-review packet is captured", "state restoration receipt is captured" ], "does_not_prove": [ "subjective mix quality", "that a supported claim candidate should be kept", "all possible mix edits" ], "local_profile_note": "A no-candidate needs_followup packet is a valid review artifact; approved-candidate and durable patch steps must require an explicit recommendation.", "source_pack_profile": "neon-step-sequencer-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search", "generated_by": "lilarcade.neon-ratchet-batch", "generated_profile_source": ".riddle-proof/profiles/neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search.json", "generated_preset": "prelim-candidate", "ratchet_intent": "turn the guitar part down a little", "ratchet_focus_tracks": [ "guitar" ], "ratchet_target_tracks": [ "guitar" ], "ratchet_direction": "down", "ratchet_max_iterations": 3 }, "evidence": { "version": "riddle-proof.profile-evidence.v1", "profile_name": "lilarcade-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search-generated-prelim-candidate", "target_url": "https://main.dlwavl00q582x.amplifyapp.com/games/drum-sequencer?song=monkberry-moon-delight-tab&mix=profile&view=trainer&instrument=bass", "baseline_policy": "invariant_only", "captured_at": "2026-05-25T06:00:03.522Z", "viewports": [ { "name": "desktop", "width": 1440, "height": 1000, "url": "https://main.dlwavl00q582x.amplifyapp.com/games/drum-sequencer?song=monkberry-moon-delight-tab&mix=profile&view=trainer&instrument=bass", "route": { "requested": "https://main.dlwavl00q582x.amplifyapp.com/games/drum-sequencer?song=monkberry-moon-delight-tab&mix=profile&view=trainer&instrument=bass", "observed": "/games/drum-sequencer", "expected_path": "/games/drum-sequencer", "matched": true, "http_status": 200 }, "title": "LilArcade", "body_text_length": 2149, "body_text_sample": "🕹️ LilArcade RHYTHM LAB Neon Step Sequencer Paint a 4-bar, 64-step loop and keep the arcade pulsing. My Sequences MONKBERRY MOON DELIGHT Bass Trainer Open Playalong Play All Shuffle Clear Debug Meters Off Verbose Off Auto-Mix Pass Auto-mix ready VERBOSE LOGS TEMPO 98 BPM Audio ready SONG Blank Yakety Yak (Dark) (G) Monkberry Moon Delight (Sheet) (C minor) Monkberry Moon Delight (Full OMR) (C minor) Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab) (C minor) Dark Progression (Em) Midnight Protocol (Am) INSTRUMENT LANES Power, source, mix, and editor focus in one place ON DRUMS Kick, snare, hat, clap, rim 208 HITS DRUM SOURCE Sampled Kit Samples + Synth Synth Drums LEVEL 0.49X Mute Sampled Kit Kick 0.90x Snare 0.67x Hat 0.34x Clap 0.27x Rim 0.29x ON BASS Low end foundation 68 NOTES BASS INSTRUMENT Dub Bass Electric Bass + Sub Electric Bass Finger Bass (SoundFont) Synth Bass LEVEL 0.62X PAN 0.01L Mute TONE Electric Bass + Sub ON VOCAL MELODY Vocal melody line 77 NOTES VOCAL INSTRUMENT Synth Vocal Voice Oohs Choir Aahs Voice Lead Synth Choir LEVEL 0.84X PAN 0.02R DELAY 0.07 Mute TONE Voice Oohs ON PAD / KEYS Harmony bed 84 NOTES KEYS INSTRUMENT Piano + Pad Piano Synth Pad LEVEL 0.16X PAN 0.22L DELAY 0.10 Mute TONE Piano + Pad ON GUITAR / LEAD LINE Hooks and strums 639 NOTES GUITAR INSTRUMENT Guitar + Synth Electric Guitar Synth Lead Line LEVEL 0.65X PAN 0.26R DELAY 0.11 Mute TONE Guitar + Synth PART: A B C D E F G H I + ARRANGEMENT 1 A B C D E F G H I · · · · · · · 17 · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · 33 · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · 49 · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · FOCUS Mix Drums Bass Vocal Melody Pad Guitar Trainer Meters BAR − 16 + 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 INSTRUMENT TRAINER 68 notes in part A PART A PLAYING Bass INSTRUMENT Drums Bass Vocal Melody Pad / Keys Guitar / Lead Line WINDOW 1 bar 2 bars 4 bars Full Mix Focus Up Solo Pick a part, slow the tempo, and ride the hit line. Use the bar buttons above to jump sections. F1 F#1 G1 G#1 A1 A#1 B1 C2 C#2 D2 F1 F#1 C2 C#2 D2 BAR 1 BAR 2 BAR 3 C2 G1 C2 G1 C2 G1 C2 G1 C2 HIT LINE Tip: layer a simple kick on 1/5/9/13 and sprinkle hats in between. Works best with headphones.", "scroll_width": 1440, "client_width": 1440, "overflow_px": 0, "bounds_overflow_px": 0, "overflow_offenders": [], "selectors": { ".drum-sequencer h1": { "count": 1, "visible_count": 1 } }, "frames": {}, "text_sequences": {}, "text_matches": {}, "text_match_samples": {}, "text_case_insensitive_samples": {}, "observations": {}, "http_statuses": {}, "link_statuses": {}, "setup_action_results": [ { "ok": true, "action": "window_eval", "ordinal": 0, "selector": null, "frame_selector": null, "optional": false, "script_length": 236, "arg_count": 0, "returned": { "available": true, "diagnostic": { "version": "neon-step-sequencer.capture-diagnostic.v1", "target": "neon-step-sequencer", "capturedAt": "2026-05-25T06:00:04.808Z", "routeState": { "proofKind": "neon-route-state", "route": "/games/drum-sequencer", "mode": "song", "selectedSong": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)", "selectedPartIndex": 0 }, "selectedSong": { "proofKind": "neon-selected-song", "selectedSong": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)", "partCount": 9, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "description": "Humanized imported-tab mix with softer vocal formants, fuller bass harmonics, darker pads, and a deeper shared room/plate space.", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 }, "proofWindows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "bars": 1, "seed": "riddle-sequencer-bed", "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "bars": 3, "seed": "riddle-sequencer-vocal-melody", "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ] } ], "eqSettings": { "kick": [ 2.2, -0.8, -3.2, -4.5, -5.5, -5, 0.8, 0 ], "snare": [ -6, -2.5, 1.4, -3, -0.6, 1.4, 0.4, -1.8 ], "hat": [ -12, -12, -12, -10, -7, -2.5, -2.2, -1.1 ], "clap": [ -12, -8, -4, -1.5, 0.8, 0, -1, -2 ], "rim": [ -12, -8, -3.5, -1.2, 0, -0.5, -1.2, -2 ], "bass": [ -1.2, 2.8, -1.4, -4.8, -6, -8, -10, -10 ], "chord": [ -8, -2.8, -4.8, -0.8, -1, -2.8, -4.8, -6.5 ], "guitar": [ -8, -4.8, -3.4, -2.2, 1.2, 1.4, 0.2, -1.8 ], "rhythmSynth": [ -10, -6, -3.8, -1.6, 0.8, 1.8, 0, -2.8 ] }, "mixLanes": { "kick": "Sub thump around 60 Hz with most low-mid box removed.", "bass": "Bass foundation around 80-160 Hz with more 120 Hz body for small speakers.", "snare": "Backbeat body near 250 Hz with controlled upper presence.", "hat": "Soft high pulse, trimmed in brittle 4-8 kHz bands.", "chord": "Darker pad bed with more room depth and less plasticky top.", "guitar": "Mid/presence lane around 1-2 kHz, wider than the pad and glued into the shared music bus.", "rhythmSynth": "Vocal melody lane in the upper mids, forward enough to survive the small-speaker monitor without crowding 1 kHz." } } }, "mixerState": { "proofKind": "neon-mixer-state", "levels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 }, "eqSettings": { "kick": [ 2.2, -0.8, -3.2, -4.5, -5.5, -5, 0.8, 0 ], "snare": [ -6, -2.5, 1.4, -3, -0.6, 1.4, 0.4, -1.8 ], "hat": [ -12, -12, -12, -10, -7, -2.5, -2.2, -1.1 ], "clap": [ -12, -8, -4, -1.5, 0.8, 0, -1, -2 ], "rim": [ -12, -8, -3.5, -1.2, 0, -0.5, -1.2, -2 ], "bass": [ -1.2, 2.8, -1.4, -4.8, -6, -8, -10, -10 ], "chord": [ -8, -2.8, -4.8, -0.8, -1, -2.8, -4.8, -6.5 ], "guitar": [ -8, -4.8, -3.4, -2.2, 1.2, 1.4, 0.2, -1.8 ], "rhythmSynth": [ -10, -6, -3.8, -1.6, 0.8, 1.8, 0, -2.8 ] }, "panSettings": { "kick": 0, "snare": 0.03, "hat": 0.24, "clap": -0.18, "rim": 0.16, "bass": -0.01, "chord": -0.22, "guitar": 0.26, "rhythmSynth": 0.02 }, "delaySettings": { "chord": { "enabled": true, "time": 0.29, "feedback": 0.12, "mix": 0.1 }, "guitar": { "enabled": true, "time": 0.19, "feedback": 0.16, "mix": 0.11 }, "rhythmSynth": { "enabled": true, "time": 0.24, "feedback": 0.1, "mix": 0.07 } }, "synthParams": { "bass": { "waveform": "triangle", "filterCutoff": 220, "filterQ": 0.92, "attack": 0.035, "release": 0.56, "peakGain": 0.25, "sustainGain": 0.14, "secondaryWaveform": "sawtooth", "secondaryGain": 0.22, "secondaryDetune": -5, "filterEnvStart": 640, "filterEnvDecay": 0.23, "decay": 0.26, "subGain": 0.08, "drive": 0.68 }, "chord": { "style": "dark", "oscType": "triangle", "oscType2": "sine", "filterCutoff": 500, "filterSettleRatio": 0.86, "attack": 0.48, "release": 1.9, "gain": 0.22, "noteAttack": 0.06, "noteDecay": 0.22, "noteSustain": 0.42, "noteRelease": 0.7, "noteFilterCutoff": 1350, "noteFilterEndRatio": 0.24, "noteDetuneRange": 3.6 }, "guitar": { "oscType": "sawtooth", "lowpassFreq": 2600, "wahFreqStart": 560, "wahFreqPeak": 1180, "wahFreqEnd": 700, "peakGain": 0.104, "release": 0.56, "detuneRange": 5, "wahQ": 0.68, "stringDamping": 0.5, "attack": 0.015, "spreadRatio": 0.2, "pickNoiseGain": 0.045, "pickFilterFreq": 2500, "pickDecay": 0.019, "bodyFreq": 620, "bodyQ": 1.15, "bodyGain": 2.8 }, "rhythmSynth": { "oscType": "triangle", "filterCutoff": 1860, "filterQ": 0.72, "attack": 0.038, "peakGain": 0.112, "decay": 0.22, "sustainGain": 0.064, "release": 0.66, "source": "voice_oohs", "oscType2": "sine", "osc2Gain": 0.22, "osc2Detune": 3, "transpose": 12, "filterEnvStart": 2650, "filterEnvDecay": 0.2, "highpassFreq": 260, "drive": 0.12, "vibratoDepth": 8, "vibratoRate": 4.7, "vibratoDelay": 0.11, "formantFreq": 1120, "formantQ": 0.85, "formantGain": 0.8 }, "humanize": { "enabled": true, "seed": "monkberry-humanized-v1", "timingMs": 8, "velocity": 0.075, "swing": 0.055, "instrumentDelayMs": { "kick": 0, "snare": 7, "hat": 3, "clap": 10, "rim": 6, "bass": 2, "chord": 5, "guitar": 9, "rhythmSynth": 12 } }, "drums": { "kick": { "freqStart": 118, "freqEnd": 43, "pitchDecay": 0.17, "decay": 0.28, "gain": 0.96, "clickGain": 0.018, "clickDecay": 0.012, "drive": 0.9 }, "snare": { "noiseFilterFreq": 520, "noiseGain": 0.18, "noiseDecay": 0.22, "toneFreq": 190, "toneGain": 0.25, "toneDecay": 0.22 }, "hat": { "filterFreq": 6100, "gain": 0.115, "decay": 0.105 }, "clap": { "filterFreq": 1120, "gain": 0.16, "burstDecay": 0.095 }, "rim": { "noiseFilterFreq": 1800, "noiseGain": 0.09, "noiseDecay": 0.075, "toneFreq": 410, "toneGain": 0.06, "toneDecay": 0.08 } }, "ambience": { "enabled": true, "room": { "enabled": true, "seconds": 0.46, "decay": 2.25, "gain": 0.11, "preDelay": 0.014, "highpass": 220, "lowpass": 5400 }, "plate": { "enabled": true, "seconds": 1.05, "decay": 2.85, "gain": 0.08, "preDelay": 0.038, "highpass": 560, "lowpass": 4600 }, "sends": { "kick": { "room": 0.008 }, "snare": { "room": 0.16, "plate": 0.055 }, "hat": { "room": 0.026 }, "clap": { "room": 0.12, "plate": 0.045 }, "rim": { "room": 0.08 }, "bass": { "room": 0.016 }, "chord": { "room": 0.11, "plate": 0.085 }, "guitar": { "room": 0.115, "plate": 0.09 }, "rhythmSynth": { "room": 0.06, "plate": 0.13 } } }, "groupBuses": { "music": { "enabled": true, "gain": 1, "drive": 1.12, "highpass": 170, "lowpass": 6200, "lowshelfFreq": 240, "lowshelfGain": -0.4, "presenceFreq": 2150, "presenceQ": 0.95, "presenceGain": -0.7, "highshelfFreq": 4700, "highshelfGain": -1.1, "compressor": { "threshold": -22, "ratio": 2.4, "attack": 0.014, "release": 0.26, "knee": 20 } } } }, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 }, "trackLabels": { "chord": "Pad / Keys", "rhythmSynth": "Vocal Melody" }, "trackRoles": { "kick": "Drum low end", "snare": "Backbeat", "hat": "Pulse", "clap": "Cymbal accents", "rim": "Toms", "bass": "With-vocal bass foundation", "chord": "Reduced harmony bed", "guitar": "Lead and rhythm guitars", "rhythmSynth": "With-vocal top line" }, "mixLanes": { "kick": "Sub thump around 60 Hz with most low-mid box removed.", "bass": "Bass foundation around 80-160 Hz with more 120 Hz body for small speakers.", "snare": "Backbeat body near 250 Hz with controlled upper presence.", "hat": "Soft high pulse, trimmed in brittle 4-8 kHz bands.", "chord": "Darker pad bed with more room depth and less plasticky top.", "guitar": "Mid/presence lane around 1-2 kHz, wider than the pad and glued into the shared music bus.", "rhythmSynth": "Vocal melody lane in the upper mids, forward enough to survive the small-speaker monitor without crowding 1 kHz." }, "proofWindows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "bars": 1, "seed": "riddle-sequencer-bed", "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "bars": 3, "seed": "riddle-sequencer-vocal-melody", "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ] } ] } }, "sourceState": { "proofKind": "neon-source-state", "drums": { "source": "samples", "status": "idle", "loadedTrackCount": 0, "loadedSampleCount": 0, "loadedSampleNames": [], "library": { "name": "LM-2 sampled drum machine", "license": "Public domain sample pack", "trackCount": 5, "sampleCount": 8, "sampleNames": [ "kick", "kick-alt", "snare-m", "hhclosed-short", "hhclosed", "hhclosed-long", "clap", "stick-m" ] } }, "bass": { "source": "hybrid", "status": "idle", "loadedSampleCount": 0, "library": { "name": "tonejs-instruments bass-electric", "license": "CC BY 3.0", "sampleCount": 6 } }, "chord": { "source": "hybrid", "status": "idle", "loadedSampleCount": 0, "library": { "name": "tonejs-instruments piano", "license": "CC BY 3.0", "sampleCount": 7 } }, "guitar": { "source": "hybrid", "status": "idle", "loadedSampleCount": 0, "library": { "name": "tonejs-instruments guitar-electric", "license": "CC BY 3.0", "sampleCount": 9 } }, "vocal": { "source": "voice_oohs", "status": "idle", "loadedSampleCount": 0, "library": { "name": "FluidR3 General MIDI SoundFont", "license": "CC BY 3.0", "instruments": [ "voice_oohs", "choir_aahs", "lead_6_voice", "synth_choir" ] } } }, "playbackState": { "proofKind": "neon-playback-state", "isPlaying": false, "selectedPartIndex": 0, "arrangement": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 ], "trainer": { "selectedInstrument": "bass", "partIndex": 0, "partLabel": "A", "sequencePosition": 0, "playbackPartIndex": null, "playbackStepCount": 256, "currentStep": 0, "eventCount": 68, "visibleEventCount": 9, "pianoKeyCount": 10, "windowBars": 2, "backingMode": "full" } }, "state": { "route": "/games/drum-sequencer", "mode": "song", "isPlaying": false, "selectedSong": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)", "selectedPartIndex": 0, "partCount": 9, "arrangement": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 ], "trainer": { "selectedInstrument": "bass", "partIndex": 0, "partLabel": "A", "sequencePosition": 0, "playbackPartIndex": null, "playbackStepCount": 256, "currentStep": 0, "eventCount": 68, "visibleEventCount": 9, "pianoKeyCount": 10, "windowBars": 2, "backingMode": "full" }, "profile": { "tempo": 98, "barCount": 16, "enabled": { "bass": true, "chord": true, "guitar": true, "rhythmSynth": true }, "labels": { "rhythmSynth": "Vocal Melody", "chord": "Pad / Keys" }, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "description": "Humanized imported-tab mix with softer vocal formants, fuller bass harmonics, darker pads, and a deeper shared room/plate space.", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 }, "proofWindows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "bars": 1, "seed": "riddle-sequencer-bed", "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "bars": 3, "seed": "riddle-sequencer-vocal-melody", "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ] } ], "eqSettings": { "kick": [ 2.2, -0.8, -3.2, -4.5, -5.5, -5, 0.8, 0 ], "snare": [ -6, -2.5, 1.4, -3, -0.6, 1.4, 0.4, -1.8 ], "hat": [ -12, -12, -12, -10, -7, -2.5, -2.2, -1.1 ], "clap": [ -12, -8, -4, -1.5, 0.8, 0, -1, -2 ], "rim": [ -12, -8, -3.5, -1.2, 0, -0.5, -1.2, -2 ], "bass": [ -1.2, 2.8, -1.4, -4.8, -6, -8, -10, -10 ], "chord": [ -8, -2.8, -4.8, -0.8, -1, -2.8, -4.8, -6.5 ], "guitar": [ -8, -4.8, -3.4, -2.2, 1.2, 1.4, 0.2, -1.8 ], "rhythmSynth": [ -10, -6, -3.8, -1.6, 0.8, 1.8, 0, -2.8 ] }, "mixLanes": { "kick": "Sub thump around 60 Hz with most low-mid box removed.", "bass": "Bass foundation around 80-160 Hz with more 120 Hz body for small speakers.", "snare": "Backbeat body near 250 Hz with controlled upper presence.", "hat": "Soft high pulse, trimmed in brittle 4-8 kHz bands.", "chord": "Darker pad bed with more room depth and less plasticky top.", "guitar": "Mid/presence lane around 1-2 kHz, wider than the pad and glued into the shared music bus.", "rhythmSynth": "Vocal melody lane in the upper mids, forward enough to survive the small-speaker monitor without crowding 1 kHz." } }, "trackRoles": { "kick": "Drum low end", "snare": "Backbeat", "hat": "Pulse", "clap": "Cymbal accents", "rim": "Toms", "bass": "With-vocal bass foundation", "chord": "Reduced harmony bed", "guitar": "Lead and rhythm guitars", "rhythmSynth": "With-vocal top line" }, "activeCounts": { "drums": 208, "bass": 68, "chord": 84, "guitar": 639, "rhythmSynth": 77 }, "activeRows": { "drums": 3, "bass": 6, "chord": 10, "guitar": 16 }, "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 }, "eqSettings": { "kick": [ 2.2, -0.8, -3.2, -4.5, -5.5, -5, 0.8, 0 ], "snare": [ -6, -2.5, 1.4, -3, -0.6, 1.4, 0.4, -1.8 ], "hat": [ -12, -12, -12, -10, -7, -2.5, -2.2, -1.1 ], "clap": [ -12, -8, -4, -1.5, 0.8, 0, -1, -2 ], "rim": [ -12, -8, -3.5, -1.2, 0, -0.5, -1.2, -2 ], "bass": [ -1.2, 2.8, -1.4, -4.8, -6, -8, -10, -10 ], "chord": [ -8, -2.8, -4.8, -0.8, -1, -2.8, -4.8, -6.5 ], "guitar": [ -8, -4.8, -3.4, -2.2, 1.2, 1.4, 0.2, -1.8 ], "rhythmSynth": [ -10, -6, -3.8, -1.6, 0.8, 1.8, 0, -2.8 ] }, "panSettings": { "kick": 0, "snare": 0.03, "hat": 0.24, "clap": -0.18, "rim": 0.16, "bass": -0.01, "chord": -0.22, "guitar": 0.26, "rhythmSynth": 0.02 }, "delaySettings": { "chord": { "enabled": true, "time": 0.29, "feedback": 0.12, "mix": 0.1 }, "guitar": { "enabled": true, "time": 0.19, "feedback": 0.16, "mix": 0.11 }, "rhythmSynth": { "enabled": true, "time": 0.24, "feedback": 0.1, "mix": 0.07 } }, "synthParams": { "bass": { "waveform": "triangle", "filterCutoff": 220, "filterQ": 0.92, "attack": 0.035, "release": 0.56, "peakGain": 0.25, "sustainGain": 0.14, "secondaryWaveform": "sawtooth", "secondaryGain": 0.22, "secondaryDetune": -5, "filterEnvStart": 640, "filterEnvDecay": 0.23, "decay": 0.26, "subGain": 0.08, "drive": 0.68 }, "chord": { "style": "dark", "oscType": "triangle", "oscType2": "sine", "filterCutoff": 500, "filterSettleRatio": 0.86, "attack": 0.48, "release": 1.9, "gain": 0.22, "noteAttack": 0.06, "noteDecay": 0.22, "noteSustain": 0.42, "noteRelease": 0.7, "noteFilterCutoff": 1350, "noteFilterEndRatio": 0.24, "noteDetuneRange": 3.6 }, "guitar": { "oscType": "sawtooth", "lowpassFreq": 2600, "wahFreqStart": 560, "wahFreqPeak": 1180, "wahFreqEnd": 700, "peakGain": 0.104, "release": 0.56, "detuneRange": 5, "wahQ": 0.68, "stringDamping": 0.5, "attack": 0.015, "spreadRatio": 0.2, "pickNoiseGain": 0.045, "pickFilterFreq": 2500, "pickDecay": 0.019, "bodyFreq": 620, "bodyQ": 1.15, "bodyGain": 2.8 }, "rhythmSynth": { "oscType": "triangle", "filterCutoff": 1860, "filterQ": 0.72, "attack": 0.038, "peakGain": 0.112, "decay": 0.22, "sustainGain": 0.064, "release": 0.66, "source": "voice_oohs", "oscType2": "sine", "osc2Gain": 0.22, "osc2Detune": 3, "transpose": 12, "filterEnvStart": 2650, "filterEnvDecay": 0.2, "highpassFreq": 260, "drive": 0.12, "vibratoDepth": 8, "vibratoRate": 4.7, "vibratoDelay": 0.11, "formantFreq": 1120, "formantQ": 0.85, "formantGain": 0.8 }, "humanize": { "enabled": true, "seed": "monkberry-humanized-v1", "timingMs": 8, "velocity": 0.075, "swing": 0.055, "instrumentDelayMs": { "kick": 0, "snare": 7, "hat": 3, "clap": 10, "rim": 6, "bass": 2, "chord": 5, "guitar": 9, "rhythmSynth": 12 } }, "drums": { "kick": { "freqStart": 118, "freqEnd": 43, "pitchDecay": 0.17, "decay": 0.28, "gain": 0.96, "clickGain": 0.018, "clickDecay": 0.012, "drive": 0.9 }, "snare": { "noiseFilterFreq": 520, "noiseGain": 0.18, "noiseDecay": 0.22, "toneFreq": 190, "toneGain": 0.25, "toneDecay": 0.22 }, "hat": { "filterFreq": 6100, "gain": 0.115, "decay": 0.105 }, "clap": { "filterFreq": 1120, "gain": 0.16, "burstDecay": 0.095 }, "rim": { "noiseFilterFreq": 1800, "noiseGain": 0.09, "noiseDecay": 0.075, "toneFreq": 410, "toneGain": 0.06, "toneDecay": 0.08 } }, "ambience": { "enabled": true, "room": { "enabled": true, "seconds": 0.46, "decay": 2.25, "gain": 0.11, "preDelay": 0.014, "highpass": 220, "lowpass": 5400 }, "plate": { "enabled": true, "seconds": 1.05, "decay": 2.85, "gain": 0.08, "preDelay": 0.038, "highpass": 560, "lowpass": 4600 }, "sends": { "kick": { "room": 0.008 }, "snare": { "room": 0.16, "plate": 0.055 }, "hat": { "room": 0.026 }, "clap": { "room": 0.12, "plate": 0.045 }, "rim": { "room": 0.08 }, "bass": { "room": 0.016 }, "chord": { "room": 0.11, "plate": 0.085 }, "guitar": { "room": 0.115, "plate": 0.09 }, "rhythmSynth": { "room": 0.06, "plate": 0.13 } } }, "groupBuses": { "music": { "enabled": true, "gain": 1, "drive": 1.12, "highpass": 170, "lowpass": 6200, "lowshelfFreq": 240, "lowshelfGain": -0.4, "presenceFreq": 2150, "presenceQ": 0.95, "presenceGain": -0.7, "highshelfFreq": 4700, "highshelfGain": -1.1, "compressor": { "threshold": -22, "ratio": 2.4, "attack": 0.014, "release": 0.26, "knee": 20 } } } } }, "supportsOfflineAudio": true } } }, "return_captured": true, "return_stored_to": "__neonMixProof.contract", "return_summary_fields": [ { "path": "available" }, { "path": "diagnostic.selectedSong.selectedSong" } ] }, { "ok": true, "action": "assert_window_value", "ordinal": 1, "selector": null, "frame_selector": null, "optional": false, "path": "__neonMixProof.contract.available", "value": true, "expected_value": true, "timeout_ms": 10000 }, { "ok": true, "action": "window_call", "ordinal": 2, "selector": null, "frame_selector": null, "optional": false, "path": "__NEON_MIX_PROOF__.runRatchetLoop", "arg_count": 1, "returned": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "neon-ratchet-loop", "status": "claim_candidate_supported", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "domain": "audio_mix", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "candidateKind": "change_claim_candidate", "focusTracks": [ "guitar" ], "requestConstraints": { "targetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "direction": "down", "source": "explicit_args", "requestedText": "turn the guitar part down a little" }, "maxIterations": 3, "restore": true, "applyBest": false, "baselineCandidateRankingMetric": 61.66285, "bestCandidateRankingMetric": 62.2099, "rankingMetricDelta": -0.547, "supportedClaimCandidateCount": 3, "preparationReceipt": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "sample-source-preparation", "sources": { "drums": "samples", "bass": "hybrid", "chord": "hybrid", "guitar": "hybrid", "vocal": "voice_oohs" }, "loaded": { "drums": true, "vocal": true, "bass": true, "chord": true, "guitar": true }, "skipped": {}, "states": { "bass": { "source": "hybrid", "status": "idle", "loadedSampleCount": 6, "library": { "name": "tonejs-instruments bass-electric", "license": "CC BY 3.0", "sampleCount": 6 } }, "chord": { "source": "hybrid", "status": "idle", "loadedSampleCount": 7, "library": { "name": "tonejs-instruments piano", "license": "CC BY 3.0", "sampleCount": 7 } }, "guitar": { "source": "hybrid", "status": "idle", "loadedSampleCount": 9, "library": { "name": "tonejs-instruments guitar-electric", "license": "CC BY 3.0", "sampleCount": 9 } }, "vocal": { "source": "voice_oohs", "status": "idle", "loadedSampleCount": 37, "library": { "name": "FluidR3 General MIDI SoundFont", "license": "CC BY 3.0", "instruments": [ "voice_oohs", "choir_aahs", "lead_6_voice", "synth_choir" ] } }, "drums": { "source": "samples", "status": "idle", "loadedTrackCount": 5, "loadedSampleCount": 8, "loadedSampleNames": [ "snare-m", "kick", "kick-alt", "stick-m", "hhclosed-long", "hhclosed-short", "hhclosed", "clap" ], "library": { "name": "LM-2 sampled drum machine", "license": "Public domain sample pack", "trackCount": 5, "sampleCount": 8, "sampleNames": [ "kick", "kick-alt", "snare-m", "hhclosed-short", "hhclosed", "hhclosed-long", "clap", "stick-m" ] } } } }, "baseline": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "offline-audio-window-set", "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } }, "windowCount": 2, "passedCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "status": "passed", "windows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "bass", "active": true, "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "active": true, "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "active": true, "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.1115, "peak": 0.7747, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.22, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 71.0141, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -5.993, "slopePenalty": 0.5538, "rolloffPenalty": 2.8473, "presenceRatio": 0.0451, "presencePenalty": 0.8398, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.122, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2159, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 71.0141, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -5.993, "slopePenalty": 0.5538, "rolloffPenalty": 2.8473, "presenceRatio": 0.0451, "presencePenalty": 0.8398, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.122, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2159, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 6, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1772, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.011746 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1014, "peak": 0.5843, "totalEnergy": 0.00364 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0113, "peak": 0.124, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 } ], "error": null }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "active": true, "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.2921, "peak": 0.7726, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.24, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 52.3116, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.824, "slopePenalty": 2.0652, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1712, "presenceRatio": 0.0386, "presencePenalty": 0.9117, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3252, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.3009, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 52.3116, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.824, "slopePenalty": 2.0652, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1712, "presenceRatio": 0.0386, "presencePenalty": 0.9117, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3252, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.3009, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 7, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1638, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.010533 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1085, "peak": 0.6418, "totalEnergy": 0.00468 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0112, "peak": 0.1242, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0264, "peak": 0.1086, "totalEnergy": 0.000114 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.002, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0517, "peak": 0.2756, "totalEnergy": 0.000451 }, { "name": "rhythmSynth", "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "error": null } ], "findings": [] }, "iterations": [ { "index": 1, "candidate": { "track": "guitar", "value": 0.6, "label": "guitar -0.05", "claimCandidate": { "id": "set-guitar-level-0.65-to-0.60", "kind": "change_claim_candidate", "domain": "audio_mix", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.60 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.6, "delta": -0.05 }, "expectedReceipts": [ "mixer edit accepted", "candidate track matches requested intent", "candidate direction matches requested intent", "contract mixer level reflects requested value", "rendered target track metrics changed", "required instruments remain active", "required section energy floors remain active", "no clipping", "headroom guardrail is preserved", "no low-level proof window" ], "rankingHint": { "metric": "objective_mix_health_penalty", "lowerIsBetter": true, "role": "review_order_only" } } }, "claimCandidate": { "id": "set-guitar-level-0.65-to-0.60", "kind": "change_claim_candidate", "domain": "audio_mix", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.60 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.6, "delta": -0.05 }, "expectedReceipts": [ "mixer edit accepted", "candidate track matches requested intent", "candidate direction matches requested intent", "contract mixer level reflects requested value", "rendered target track metrics changed", "required instruments remain active", "required section energy floors remain active", "no clipping", "headroom guardrail is preserved", "no low-level proof window" ], "rankingHint": { "metric": "objective_mix_health_penalty", "lowerIsBetter": true, "role": "review_order_only" } }, "baselineRestoreReceipts": [ { "ok": true, "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "before": 0.65, "value": 0.65, "levels": null } ], "edit": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "before": 0.65, "value": 0.6, "levels": null }, "claimReceipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true, "evidence": { "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "error": null } }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true, "evidence": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" } }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true, "evidence": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.05, "source": "explicit_args" } }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true, "evidence": { "track": "guitar", "expectedLevel": 0.6, "observedLevel": 0.6 } }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true, "evidence": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0462, "peak": 0.252, "totalEnergy": 0.000374 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.04265, "peak": 0.23275, "totalEnergy": 0.00032 }, "deltas": { "rms": -0.00355, "peak": -0.01925, "totalEnergy": -0.000054 }, "thresholds": { "rms": 0.00001, "peak": 0.00001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } } }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "findings": [] } }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "sectionCount": 2, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } } ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ] } ] } }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true, "evidence": { "clippingWindows": [] } }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "headroomDb": 2.34, "headroomOk": true }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "headroomDb": 2.36, "headroomOk": true } ] } }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true, "evidence": { "lowLevelWindows": [] } } ], "claimVerdict": { "ok": true, "status": "supported", "classification": null, "failedReceipts": [] }, "candidateRankingMetric": 62.2099, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.2405, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.1115, "peak": 0.7747, "totalEnergy": 0.015805, "loudnessStyleLufs": -19.75, "headroomDb": 2.22, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.106, "peak": 0.7639, "totalEnergy": 0.015761, "loudnessStyleLufs": -20.18, "headroomDb": 2.34, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0055, "peak": -0.0108, "totalEnergy": -0.000044, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.43, "headroomDb": 0.12 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0031, "peak": -0.0175, "totalEnergy": -0.000044 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.34, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2921, "peak": 0.7726, "totalEnergy": 0.015827, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.38, "headroomDb": 2.24, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2904, "peak": 0.7619, "totalEnergy": 0.015761, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.43, "headroomDb": 2.36, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0017, "peak": -0.0107, "totalEnergy": -0.000066, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.05, "headroomDb": 0.12 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0517, "peak": 0.2756, "totalEnergy": 0.000451 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0477, "peak": 0.2546, "totalEnergy": 0.000385 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.004, "peak": -0.021, "totalEnergy": -0.000066 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.36, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.24, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000055, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "offline-audio-window-set", "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } }, "windowCount": 2, "passedCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "status": "passed", "windows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "bass", "active": true, "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "active": true, "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "active": true, "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.106, "peak": 0.7639, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.34, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 71.3476, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.047, "slopePenalty": 0.6222, "rolloffPenalty": 2.868, "presenceRatio": 0.0451, "presencePenalty": 0.8398, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.122, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2144, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 71.3476, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.047, "slopePenalty": 0.6222, "rolloffPenalty": 2.868, "presenceRatio": 0.0451, "presencePenalty": 0.8398, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.122, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2144, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 6, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1772, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.011746 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1014, "peak": 0.5843, "totalEnergy": 0.00364 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0113, "peak": 0.124, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } ], "error": null }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "active": true, "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.2904, "peak": 0.7619, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.36, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 52.5912, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.853, "slopePenalty": 2.135, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1713, "presenceRatio": 0.0386, "presencePenalty": 0.9117, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3252, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2985, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 52.5912, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.853, "slopePenalty": 2.135, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1713, "presenceRatio": 0.0386, "presencePenalty": 0.9117, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3252, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2985, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 7, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1638, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.010533 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1085, "peak": 0.6418, "totalEnergy": 0.00468 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0112, "peak": 0.1242, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0264, "peak": 0.1086, "totalEnergy": 0.000114 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.002, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0477, "peak": 0.2546, "totalEnergy": 0.000385 }, { "name": "rhythmSynth", "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "error": null } ], "findings": [] } }, { "index": 2, "candidate": { "track": "guitar", "value": 0.55, "label": "guitar -0.10", "claimCandidate": { "id": "set-guitar-level-0.65-to-0.55", "kind": "change_claim_candidate", "domain": "audio_mix", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.55 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.1 }, "expectedReceipts": [ "mixer edit accepted", "candidate track matches requested intent", "candidate direction matches requested intent", "contract mixer level reflects requested value", "rendered target track metrics changed", "required instruments remain active", "required section energy floors remain active", "no clipping", "headroom guardrail is preserved", "no low-level proof window" ], "rankingHint": { "metric": "objective_mix_health_penalty", "lowerIsBetter": true, "role": "review_order_only" } } }, "claimCandidate": { "id": "set-guitar-level-0.65-to-0.55", "kind": "change_claim_candidate", "domain": "audio_mix", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.55 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.1 }, "expectedReceipts": [ "mixer edit accepted", "candidate track matches requested intent", "candidate direction matches requested intent", "contract mixer level reflects requested value", "rendered target track metrics changed", "required instruments remain active", "required section energy floors remain active", "no clipping", "headroom guardrail is preserved", "no low-level proof window" ], "rankingHint": { "metric": "objective_mix_health_penalty", "lowerIsBetter": true, "role": "review_order_only" } }, "baselineRestoreReceipts": [ { "ok": true, "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "before": 0.6, "value": 0.65, "levels": null } ], "edit": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "before": 0.65, "value": 0.55, "levels": null }, "claimReceipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true, "evidence": { "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "error": null } }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true, "evidence": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" } }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true, "evidence": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.1, "source": "explicit_args" } }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true, "evidence": { "track": "guitar", "expectedLevel": 0.55, "observedLevel": 0.55 } }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true, "evidence": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0462, "peak": 0.252, "totalEnergy": 0.000374 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0391, "peak": 0.21335, "totalEnergy": 0.000268 }, "deltas": { "rms": -0.0071, "peak": -0.03865, "totalEnergy": -0.000106 }, "thresholds": { "rms": 0.00001, "peak": 0.00001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } } }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "findings": [] } }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "sectionCount": 2, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0345, "peak": 0.1933, "totalEnergy": 0.000214 } } ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ] } ] } }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true, "evidence": { "clippingWindows": [] } }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "headroomDb": 2.47, "headroomOk": true }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "headroomDb": 2.49, "headroomOk": true } ] } }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true, "evidence": { "lowLevelWindows": [] } } ], "claimVerdict": { "ok": true, "status": "supported", "classification": null, "failedReceipts": [] }, "candidateRankingMetric": 62.73524999999999, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.5111, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.1115, "peak": 0.7747, "totalEnergy": 0.015805, "loudnessStyleLufs": -19.75, "headroomDb": 2.22, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.1004, "peak": 0.7527, "totalEnergy": 0.015721, "loudnessStyleLufs": -20.66, "headroomDb": 2.47, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0111, "peak": -0.022, "totalEnergy": -0.000084, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.91, "headroomDb": 0.25 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0345, "peak": 0.1933, "totalEnergy": 0.000214 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0062, "peak": -0.0351, "totalEnergy": -0.000084 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0345, "peak": 0.1933, "totalEnergy": 0.000214 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.47, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2921, "peak": 0.7726, "totalEnergy": 0.015827, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.38, "headroomDb": 2.24, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2888, "peak": 0.7508, "totalEnergy": 0.015699, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.48, "headroomDb": 2.49, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0033, "peak": -0.0218, "totalEnergy": -0.000128, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.1, "headroomDb": 0.25 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0517, "peak": 0.2756, "totalEnergy": 0.000451 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0437, "peak": 0.2334, "totalEnergy": 0.000323 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.008, "peak": -0.0422, "totalEnergy": -0.000128 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.49, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.51, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000106, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "offline-audio-window-set", "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } }, "windowCount": 2, "passedCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "status": "passed", "windows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "bass", "active": true, "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "active": true, "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "active": true, "rms": 0.0345, "peak": 0.1933, "totalEnergy": 0.000214 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.1004, "peak": 0.7527, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.47, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 71.6643, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.095, "slopePenalty": 0.688, "rolloffPenalty": 2.8906, "presenceRatio": 0.0452, "presencePenalty": 0.8387, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.119, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2132, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 71.6643, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.095, "slopePenalty": 0.688, "rolloffPenalty": 2.8906, "presenceRatio": 0.0452, "presencePenalty": 0.8387, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.119, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2132, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 6, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1772, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.011746 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1014, "peak": 0.5843, "totalEnergy": 0.00364 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0113, "peak": 0.124, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0345, "peak": 0.1933, "totalEnergy": 0.000214 } ], "error": null }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "active": true, "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.2888, "peak": 0.7508, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.49, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 52.784, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.874, "slopePenalty": 2.1861, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1735, "presenceRatio": 0.0387, "presencePenalty": 0.9106, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3219, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2963, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 52.784, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.874, "slopePenalty": 2.1861, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1735, "presenceRatio": 0.0387, "presencePenalty": 0.9106, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3219, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2963, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 7, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1638, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.010533 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1085, "peak": 0.6418, "totalEnergy": 0.00468 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0112, "peak": 0.1242, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0264, "peak": 0.1086, "totalEnergy": 0.000114 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.002, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0437, "peak": 0.2334, "totalEnergy": 0.000323 }, { "name": "rhythmSynth", "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "error": null } ], "findings": [] } }, { "index": 3, "candidate": { "track": "guitar", "value": 0.47000000000000003, "label": "guitar -0.18", "claimCandidate": { "id": "set-guitar-level-0.65-to-0.47", "kind": "change_claim_candidate", "domain": "audio_mix", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.47 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.47000000000000003, "delta": -0.18 }, "expectedReceipts": [ "mixer edit accepted", "candidate track matches requested intent", "candidate direction matches requested intent", "contract mixer level reflects requested value", "rendered target track metrics changed", "required instruments remain active", "required section energy floors remain active", "no clipping", "headroom guardrail is preserved", "no low-level proof window" ], "rankingHint": { "metric": "objective_mix_health_penalty", "lowerIsBetter": true, "role": "review_order_only" } } }, "claimCandidate": { "id": "set-guitar-level-0.65-to-0.47", "kind": "change_claim_candidate", "domain": "audio_mix", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.47 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.47000000000000003, "delta": -0.18 }, "expectedReceipts": [ "mixer edit accepted", "candidate track matches requested intent", "candidate direction matches requested intent", "contract mixer level reflects requested value", "rendered target track metrics changed", "required instruments remain active", "required section energy floors remain active", "no clipping", "headroom guardrail is preserved", "no low-level proof window" ], "rankingHint": { "metric": "objective_mix_health_penalty", "lowerIsBetter": true, "role": "review_order_only" } }, "baselineRestoreReceipts": [ { "ok": true, "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "before": 0.55, "value": 0.65, "levels": null } ], "edit": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "before": 0.65, "value": 0.47000000000000003, "levels": null }, "claimReceipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true, "evidence": { "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "error": null } }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true, "evidence": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" } }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true, "evidence": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.18, "source": "explicit_args" } }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true, "evidence": { "track": "guitar", "expectedLevel": 0.47000000000000003, "observedLevel": 0.47 } }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true, "evidence": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0462, "peak": 0.252, "totalEnergy": 0.000374 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.03345, "peak": 0.1823, "totalEnergy": 0.000196 }, "deltas": { "rms": -0.01275, "peak": -0.0697, "totalEnergy": -0.000178 }, "thresholds": { "rms": 0.00001, "peak": 0.00001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } } }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "findings": [] } }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "sectionCount": 2, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0295, "peak": 0.1652, "totalEnergy": 0.000156 } } ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ] } ] } }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true, "evidence": { "clippingWindows": [] } }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "headroomDb": 2.69, "headroomOk": true }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "headroomDb": 2.65, "headroomOk": true } ] } }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true, "evidence": { "lowLevelWindows": [] } } ], "claimVerdict": { "ok": true, "status": "supported", "classification": null, "failedReceipts": [] }, "candidateRankingMetric": 63.672599999999996, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.9518, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.1115, "peak": 0.7747, "totalEnergy": 0.015805, "loudnessStyleLufs": -19.75, "headroomDb": 2.22, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0913, "peak": 0.7334, "totalEnergy": 0.015663, "loudnessStyleLufs": -21.48, "headroomDb": 2.69, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0202, "peak": -0.0413, "totalEnergy": -0.000142, "loudnessStyleLufs": -1.73, "headroomDb": 0.47 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0295, "peak": 0.1652, "totalEnergy": 0.000156 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0112, "peak": -0.0632, "totalEnergy": -0.000142 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0295, "peak": 0.1652, "totalEnergy": 0.000156 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.69, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2921, "peak": 0.7726, "totalEnergy": 0.015827, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.38, "headroomDb": 2.24, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2863, "peak": 0.7371, "totalEnergy": 0.015612, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.55, "headroomDb": 2.65, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0058, "peak": -0.0355, "totalEnergy": -0.000215, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.17, "headroomDb": 0.41 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0517, "peak": 0.2756, "totalEnergy": 0.000451 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0374, "peak": 0.1994, "totalEnergy": 0.000236 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0143, "peak": -0.0762, "totalEnergy": -0.000215 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.65, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.95, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000179, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "offline-audio-window-set", "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } }, "windowCount": 2, "passedCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "status": "passed", "windows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "bass", "active": true, "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "active": true, "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "active": true, "rms": 0.0295, "peak": 0.1652, "totalEnergy": 0.000156 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.0913, "peak": 0.7334, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.69, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 72.2397, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.18, "slopePenalty": 0.8101, "rolloffPenalty": 2.93, "presenceRatio": 0.0454, "presencePenalty": 0.8365, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.113, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2113, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 72.2397, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.18, "slopePenalty": 0.8101, "rolloffPenalty": 2.93, "presenceRatio": 0.0454, "presencePenalty": 0.8365, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.113, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2113, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 6, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1772, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.011746 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1014, "peak": 0.5843, "totalEnergy": 0.00364 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0113, "peak": 0.124, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0295, "peak": 0.1652, "totalEnergy": 0.000156 } ], "error": null }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "active": true, "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.2863, "peak": 0.7371, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.65, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 53.2019, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.914, "slopePenalty": 2.2864, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1735, "presenceRatio": 0.0386, "presencePenalty": 0.9117, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3252, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2932, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 53.2019, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.914, "slopePenalty": 2.2864, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1735, "presenceRatio": 0.0386, "presencePenalty": 0.9117, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3252, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2932, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 7, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1638, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.010533 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1085, "peak": 0.6418, "totalEnergy": 0.00468 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0112, "peak": 0.1242, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0264, "peak": 0.1086, "totalEnergy": 0.000114 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.002, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0374, "peak": 0.1994, "totalEnergy": 0.000236 }, { "name": "rhythmSynth", "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "error": null } ], "findings": [] } } ], "best": { "index": 1, "candidate": { "track": "guitar", "value": 0.6, "label": "guitar -0.05", "claimCandidate": { "id": "set-guitar-level-0.65-to-0.60", "kind": "change_claim_candidate", "domain": "audio_mix", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.60 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.6, "delta": -0.05 }, "expectedReceipts": [ "mixer edit accepted", "candidate track matches requested intent", "candidate direction matches requested intent", "contract mixer level reflects requested value", "rendered target track metrics changed", "required instruments remain active", "required section energy floors remain active", "no clipping", "headroom guardrail is preserved", "no low-level proof window" ], "rankingHint": { "metric": "objective_mix_health_penalty", "lowerIsBetter": true, "role": "review_order_only" } } }, "claimCandidate": { "id": "set-guitar-level-0.65-to-0.60", "kind": "change_claim_candidate", "domain": "audio_mix", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.60 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.6, "delta": -0.05 }, "expectedReceipts": [ "mixer edit accepted", "candidate track matches requested intent", "candidate direction matches requested intent", "contract mixer level reflects requested value", "rendered target track metrics changed", "required instruments remain active", "required section energy floors remain active", "no clipping", "headroom guardrail is preserved", "no low-level proof window" ], "rankingHint": { "metric": "objective_mix_health_penalty", "lowerIsBetter": true, "role": "review_order_only" } }, "baselineRestoreReceipts": [ { "ok": true, "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "before": 0.65, "value": 0.65, "levels": null } ], "edit": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "before": 0.65, "value": 0.6, "levels": null }, "claimReceipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true, "evidence": { "proofKind": "neon-mixer-edit", "track": "guitar", "error": null } }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true, "evidence": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" } }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true, "evidence": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.05, "source": "explicit_args" } }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true, "evidence": { "track": "guitar", "expectedLevel": 0.6, "observedLevel": 0.6 } }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true, "evidence": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0462, "peak": 0.252, "totalEnergy": 0.000374 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.04265, "peak": 0.23275, "totalEnergy": 0.00032 }, "deltas": { "rms": -0.00355, "peak": -0.01925, "totalEnergy": -0.000054 }, "thresholds": { "rms": 0.00001, "peak": 0.00001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } } }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "findings": [] } }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "sectionCount": 2, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } } ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ] } ] } }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true, "evidence": { "clippingWindows": [] } }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true, "evidence": { "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "headroomDb": 2.34, "headroomOk": true }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "headroomDb": 2.36, "headroomOk": true } ] } }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true, "evidence": { "lowLevelWindows": [] } } ], "claimVerdict": { "ok": true, "status": "supported", "classification": null, "failedReceipts": [] }, "candidateRankingMetric": 62.2099, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.2405, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.1115, "peak": 0.7747, "totalEnergy": 0.015805, "loudnessStyleLufs": -19.75, "headroomDb": 2.22, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.106, "peak": 0.7639, "totalEnergy": 0.015761, "loudnessStyleLufs": -20.18, "headroomDb": 2.34, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0055, "peak": -0.0108, "totalEnergy": -0.000044, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.43, "headroomDb": 0.12 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0031, "peak": -0.0175, "totalEnergy": -0.000044 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.34, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2921, "peak": 0.7726, "totalEnergy": 0.015827, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.38, "headroomDb": 2.24, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2904, "peak": 0.7619, "totalEnergy": 0.015761, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.43, "headroomDb": 2.36, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0017, "peak": -0.0107, "totalEnergy": -0.000066, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.05, "headroomDb": 0.12 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0517, "peak": 0.2756, "totalEnergy": 0.000451 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0477, "peak": 0.2546, "totalEnergy": 0.000385 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.004, "peak": -0.021, "totalEnergy": -0.000066 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.36, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.24, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000055, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "ok": true, "proofKind": "offline-audio-window-set", "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } }, "windowCount": 2, "passedCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "status": "passed", "windows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "bass", "active": true, "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "active": true, "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "active": true, "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.106, "peak": 0.7639, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.34, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 71.3476, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.047, "slopePenalty": 0.6222, "rolloffPenalty": 2.868, "presenceRatio": 0.0451, "presencePenalty": 0.8398, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.122, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2144, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 71.3476, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.047, "slopePenalty": 0.6222, "rolloffPenalty": 2.868, "presenceRatio": 0.0451, "presencePenalty": 0.8398, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.122, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2144, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "kick", "score": 89.342, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "snare", "score": 57.978, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.228, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 6, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1772, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.011746 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1014, "peak": 0.5843, "totalEnergy": 0.00364 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0113, "peak": 0.124, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } ], "error": null }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "ok": true, "status": "passed", "classification": null, "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ], "requiredInstruments": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "active": true, "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "mixHealth": { "rms": 0.2904, "peak": 0.7619, "clipping": false, "headroomDb": 2.36, "lowLevel": false }, "objectivePenalty": { "total": 52.5912, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.853, "slopePenalty": 2.135, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1713, "presenceRatio": 0.0386, "presencePenalty": 0.9117, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3252, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2985, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "score": { "total": 52.5912, "mix": { "slopeDbPerOct": -6.853, "slopePenalty": 2.135, "rolloffPenalty": 3.1713, "presenceRatio": 0.0386, "presencePenalty": 0.9117, "presenceFloorPenalty": 1.3252, "mixPenaltyScale": 1 }, "mud": { "ratio": 0.2985, "penalty": 0 }, "top": [ { "instrument": "snare", "score": 40.261, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "kick", "score": 17.84, "skipped": false }, { "instrument": "hat", "score": 2.227, "skipped": false } ], "eqPenalty": 3.3732 }, "activeInstrumentCount": 7, "activeInstruments": [ { "name": "kick", "rms": 0.1638, "peak": 0.8076, "totalEnergy": 0.010533 }, { "name": "snare", "rms": 0.1085, "peak": 0.6418, "totalEnergy": 0.00468 }, { "name": "hat", "rms": 0.0112, "peak": 0.1242, "totalEnergy": 0.000033 }, { "name": "bass", "rms": 0.0264, "peak": 0.1086, "totalEnergy": 0.000114 }, { "name": "chord", "rms": 0.002, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "rms": 0.0477, "peak": 0.2546, "totalEnergy": 0.000385 }, { "name": "rhythmSynth", "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ], "error": null } ], "findings": [] } }, "bestClaimCandidate": { "id": "set-guitar-level-0.65-to-0.60", "kind": "change_claim_candidate", "domain": "audio_mix", "strategy": "mix-level-search", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.60 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.6, "delta": -0.05 }, "expectedReceipts": [ "mixer edit accepted", "candidate track matches requested intent", "candidate direction matches requested intent", "contract mixer level reflects requested value", "rendered target track metrics changed", "required instruments remain active", "required section energy floors remain active", "no clipping", "headroom guardrail is preserved", "no low-level proof window" ], "rankingHint": { "metric": "objective_mix_health_penalty", "lowerIsBetter": true, "role": "review_order_only" } }, "humanReviewPacket": { "version": "neon-step-sequencer.human-review-packet.v1", "kind": "human_review_packet", "domain": "audio_mix", "status": "candidate_ready_for_listening_review", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "proofBoundary": "Objective receipts support or reject candidate change claims; musical taste still requires listening review.", "requestedIntent": "turn the guitar part down a little", "target": { "routeState": { "proofKind": "neon-route-state", "route": "/games/drum-sequencer", "mode": "song", "selectedSong": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)", "selectedPartIndex": 0 }, "selectedSong": { "proofKind": "neon-selected-song", "selectedSong": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)", "partCount": 9, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "description": "Humanized imported-tab mix with softer vocal formants, fuller bass harmonics, darker pads, and a deeper shared room/plate space.", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 }, "proofWindows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "bars": 1, "seed": "riddle-sequencer-bed", "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "bars": 3, "seed": "riddle-sequencer-vocal-melody", "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ] } ], "eqSettings": { "kick": [ 2.2, -0.8, -3.2, -4.5, -5.5, -5, 0.8, 0 ], "snare": [ -6, -2.5, 1.4, -3, -0.6, 1.4, 0.4, -1.8 ], "hat": [ -12, -12, -12, -10, -7, -2.5, -2.2, -1.1 ], "clap": [ -12, -8, -4, -1.5, 0.8, 0, -1, -2 ], "rim": [ -12, -8, -3.5, -1.2, 0, -0.5, -1.2, -2 ], "bass": [ -1.2, 2.8, -1.4, -4.8, -6, -8, -10, -10 ], "chord": [ -8, -2.8, -4.8, -0.8, -1, -2.8, -4.8, -6.5 ], "guitar": [ -8, -4.8, -3.4, -2.2, 1.2, 1.4, 0.2, -1.8 ], "rhythmSynth": [ -10, -6, -3.8, -1.6, 0.8, 1.8, 0, -2.8 ] }, "mixLanes": { "kick": "Sub thump around 60 Hz with most low-mid box removed.", "bass": "Bass foundation around 80-160 Hz with more 120 Hz body for small speakers.", "snare": "Backbeat body near 250 Hz with controlled upper presence.", "hat": "Soft high pulse, trimmed in brittle 4-8 kHz bands.", "chord": "Darker pad bed with more room depth and less plasticky top.", "guitar": "Mid/presence lane around 1-2 kHz, wider than the pad and glued into the shared music bus.", "rhythmSynth": "Vocal melody lane in the upper mids, forward enough to survive the small-speaker monitor without crowding 1 kHz." } } } }, "request": { "strategy": "mix-level-search", "focusTracks": [ "guitar" ], "claimTarget": { "targetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "direction": "down", "source": "explicit_args", "boundary": "Requested target and direction constrain objective candidate support; ranking still only orders listening review." }, "maxIterations": 3, "monitorProfile": "smallSpeaker", "restore": true, "applyBest": false, "candidateActionsAreTransient": true, "approval": null }, "recommendation": { "action": "review_before_applying_candidate", "candidate": { "index": 1, "label": "guitar -0.05", "status": "supported", "classification": null, "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.60 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.6, "delta": -0.05 }, "rankingMetric": 62.2099, "receipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true } ], "failedReceipts": [], "guardrails": { "mixerEditAccepted": true, "candidateTrackMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "candidateDirectionMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "contractLevelReflected": true, "renderedTargetMoved": true, "requiredInstrumentsPreserved": true, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "noClipping": true, "headroomPreserved": true, "noLowLevelProofWindow": true }, "targetMovement": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "deltas": { "rms": -0.00355, "peak": -0.01925, "totalEnergy": -0.000054 }, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0462, "peak": 0.252, "totalEnergy": 0.000374 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.04265, "peak": 0.23275, "totalEnergy": 0.00032 } }, "requestedIntentMatch": { "track": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" }, "direction": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.05, "source": "explicit_args" } }, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.2405, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.1115, "peak": 0.7747, "totalEnergy": 0.015805, "loudnessStyleLufs": -19.75, "headroomDb": 2.22, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.106, "peak": 0.7639, "totalEnergy": 0.015761, "loudnessStyleLufs": -20.18, "headroomDb": 2.34, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0055, "peak": -0.0108, "totalEnergy": -0.000044, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.43, "headroomDb": 0.12 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0031, "peak": -0.0175, "totalEnergy": -0.000044 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.34, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2921, "peak": 0.7726, "totalEnergy": 0.015827, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.38, "headroomDb": 2.24, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2904, "peak": 0.7619, "totalEnergy": 0.015761, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.43, "headroomDb": 2.36, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0017, "peak": -0.0107, "totalEnergy": -0.000066, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.05, "headroomDb": 0.12 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0517, "peak": 0.2756, "totalEnergy": 0.000451 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0477, "peak": 0.2546, "totalEnergy": 0.000385 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.004, "peak": -0.021, "totalEnergy": -0.000066 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.36, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.24, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000055, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "status": "passed", "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } } } }, "reason": "All objective claim receipts passed for this candidate; ranking only orders listening review." }, "supportedCandidates": [ { "index": 1, "label": "guitar -0.05", "status": "supported", "classification": null, "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.60 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.6, "delta": -0.05 }, "rankingMetric": 62.2099, "receipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true } ], "failedReceipts": [], "guardrails": { "mixerEditAccepted": true, "candidateTrackMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "candidateDirectionMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "contractLevelReflected": true, "renderedTargetMoved": true, "requiredInstrumentsPreserved": true, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "noClipping": true, "headroomPreserved": true, "noLowLevelProofWindow": true }, "targetMovement": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "deltas": { "rms": -0.00355, "peak": -0.01925, "totalEnergy": -0.000054 }, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0462, "peak": 0.252, "totalEnergy": 0.000374 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.04265, "peak": 0.23275, "totalEnergy": 0.00032 } }, "requestedIntentMatch": { "track": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" }, "direction": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.05, "source": "explicit_args" } }, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.2405, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.1115, "peak": 0.7747, "totalEnergy": 0.015805, "loudnessStyleLufs": -19.75, "headroomDb": 2.22, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.106, "peak": 0.7639, "totalEnergy": 0.015761, "loudnessStyleLufs": -20.18, "headroomDb": 2.34, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0055, "peak": -0.0108, "totalEnergy": -0.000044, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.43, "headroomDb": 0.12 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0031, "peak": -0.0175, "totalEnergy": -0.000044 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0376, "peak": 0.2109, "totalEnergy": 0.000254 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.34, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2921, "peak": 0.7726, "totalEnergy": 0.015827, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.38, "headroomDb": 2.24, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2904, "peak": 0.7619, "totalEnergy": 0.015761, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.43, "headroomDb": 2.36, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0017, "peak": -0.0107, "totalEnergy": -0.000066, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.05, "headroomDb": 0.12 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0517, "peak": 0.2756, "totalEnergy": 0.000451 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0477, "peak": 0.2546, "totalEnergy": 0.000385 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.004, "peak": -0.021, "totalEnergy": -0.000066 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.36, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.24, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000055, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "status": "passed", "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } } } }, { "index": 2, "label": "guitar -0.10", "status": "supported", "classification": null, "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.55 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.1 }, "rankingMetric": 62.7352, "receipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true } ], "failedReceipts": [], "guardrails": { "mixerEditAccepted": true, "candidateTrackMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "candidateDirectionMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "contractLevelReflected": true, "renderedTargetMoved": true, "requiredInstrumentsPreserved": true, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "noClipping": true, "headroomPreserved": true, "noLowLevelProofWindow": true }, "targetMovement": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "deltas": { "rms": -0.0071, "peak": -0.03865, "totalEnergy": -0.000106 }, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0462, "peak": 0.252, "totalEnergy": 0.000374 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0391, "peak": 0.21335, "totalEnergy": 0.000268 } }, "requestedIntentMatch": { "track": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" }, "direction": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.1, "source": "explicit_args" } }, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.5111, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.1115, "peak": 0.7747, "totalEnergy": 0.015805, "loudnessStyleLufs": -19.75, "headroomDb": 2.22, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.1004, "peak": 0.7527, "totalEnergy": 0.015721, "loudnessStyleLufs": -20.66, "headroomDb": 2.47, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0111, "peak": -0.022, "totalEnergy": -0.000084, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.91, "headroomDb": 0.25 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0345, "peak": 0.1933, "totalEnergy": 0.000214 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0062, "peak": -0.0351, "totalEnergy": -0.000084 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0345, "peak": 0.1933, "totalEnergy": 0.000214 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.47, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2921, "peak": 0.7726, "totalEnergy": 0.015827, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.38, "headroomDb": 2.24, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2888, "peak": 0.7508, "totalEnergy": 0.015699, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.48, "headroomDb": 2.49, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0033, "peak": -0.0218, "totalEnergy": -0.000128, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.1, "headroomDb": 0.25 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0517, "peak": 0.2756, "totalEnergy": 0.000451 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0437, "peak": 0.2334, "totalEnergy": 0.000323 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.008, "peak": -0.0422, "totalEnergy": -0.000128 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.49, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.51, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000106, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "status": "passed", "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } } } }, { "index": 3, "label": "guitar -0.18", "status": "supported", "classification": null, "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.65 to 0.47 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.65, "to": 0.47, "delta": -0.18 }, "rankingMetric": 63.6726, "receipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true } ], "failedReceipts": [], "guardrails": { "mixerEditAccepted": true, "candidateTrackMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "candidateDirectionMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "contractLevelReflected": true, "renderedTargetMoved": true, "requiredInstrumentsPreserved": true, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "noClipping": true, "headroomPreserved": true, "noLowLevelProofWindow": true }, "targetMovement": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "deltas": { "rms": -0.01275, "peak": -0.0697, "totalEnergy": -0.000178 }, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0462, "peak": 0.252, "totalEnergy": 0.000374 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.03345, "peak": 0.1823, "totalEnergy": 0.000196 } }, "requestedIntentMatch": { "track": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" }, "direction": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.18, "source": "explicit_args" } }, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.9518, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.1115, "peak": 0.7747, "totalEnergy": 0.015805, "loudnessStyleLufs": -19.75, "headroomDb": 2.22, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0913, "peak": 0.7334, "totalEnergy": 0.015663, "loudnessStyleLufs": -21.48, "headroomDb": 2.69, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0202, "peak": -0.0413, "totalEnergy": -0.000142, "loudnessStyleLufs": -1.73, "headroomDb": 0.47 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0295, "peak": 0.1652, "totalEnergy": 0.000156 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0112, "peak": -0.0632, "totalEnergy": -0.000142 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0407, "peak": 0.2284, "totalEnergy": 0.000298 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0295, "peak": 0.1652, "totalEnergy": 0.000156 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.69, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2921, "peak": 0.7726, "totalEnergy": 0.015827, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.38, "headroomDb": 2.24, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2863, "peak": 0.7371, "totalEnergy": 0.015612, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.55, "headroomDb": 2.65, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0058, "peak": -0.0355, "totalEnergy": -0.000215, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.17, "headroomDb": 0.41 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0517, "peak": 0.2756, "totalEnergy": 0.000451 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0374, "peak": 0.1994, "totalEnergy": 0.000236 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0143, "peak": -0.0762, "totalEnergy": -0.000215 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.65, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.95, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000179, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "status": "passed", "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } } } } ], "rejectedCandidates": [], "ranking": { "metric": "guardrail_preserving_section_energy_review_order", "role": "review_order_only", "lowerIsBetter": true, "baselineCandidateRankingMetric": 61.6628, "bestCandidateRankingMetric": 62.2099, "rankingMetricDelta": -0.547, "sectionHeuristics": { "enabled": true, "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "loudnessStyle": "rms_dbfs_estimate", "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Section-energy and loudness-style metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." } }, "baseline": { "status": "passed", "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.65, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } } }, "guardrails": { "supportedClaimCandidateCount": 3, "rejectedCandidateCount": 0, "stateRestoredAfterLoop": true, "noPermanentEditUnlessApplyBest": true, "approvedCandidateApplied": null }, "listenerPrompts": [ "Does the supported candidate match the requested musical intent?", "Is the changed part better balanced in the proof window?", "Did the proof window contain the musical material being judged?", "Would another section or speaker profile change the listening decision?" ], "caveats": [ "This packet does not prove subjective mix quality.", "A supported candidate proves objective receipts and guardrails only.", "Ranking orders review; it is not a taste score.", "Section-energy and loudness-style metrics are review aids, not proof that a candidate sounds better.", "Keep or apply the candidate only after listening review." ] }, "restorationReceipt": { "name": "state_restored_after_claim_candidate_loop", "ok": true, "expectedLevels": { "guitar": 0.65 }, "observedLevels": { "guitar": 0.65 } }, "appliedCandidateReceipt": null, "classification": null, "caveats": [ "candidateRankingMetric is only a review-order hint", "sectionEnergyComparison is a loudness-style and energy-floor review aid, not a taste score", "claim verdicts come from receipts and invariants, not taste optimization", "human listening review is required before accepting any musical change", "candidate actions are transient unless applyBest is true" ] }, "return_captured": true, "return_stored_to": "__neonMixProof.ratchetLoop", "return_summary_fields": [ { "path": "ok" }, { "path": "status" }, { "path": "strategy" }, { "path": "best.claimVerdict.status" }, { "path": "best.claimCandidate.action.track" }, { "path": "supportedClaimCandidateCount" }, { "path": "humanReviewPacket.status" }, { "path": "humanReviewPacket.recommendation.candidate.action.track" }, { "path": "humanReviewPacket.ranking.role" }, { "path": "humanReviewPacket.ranking.metric" }, { "path": "humanReviewPacket.recommendation.candidate.sectionEnergyComparison.requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved" }, { "path": "humanReviewPacket.recommendation.candidate.sectionEnergyComparison.guardrailsPreserved" }, { "path": "requestConstraints.targetTracks" }, { "path": "requestConstraints.direction" }, { "path": "humanReviewPacket.request.claimTarget.targetTracks" }, { "path": "humanReviewPacket.request.claimTarget.direction" }, { "path": "humanReviewPacket.guardrails.supportedClaimCandidateCount" }, { "path": "humanReviewPacket.guardrails.rejectedCandidateCount" } ] }, { "ok": true, "action": "assert_window_value", "ordinal": 3, "selector": null, "frame_selector": null, "optional": false, "path": "__neonMixProof.ratchetLoop.humanReviewPacket.kind", "value": "human_review_packet", "expected_value": "human_review_packet", "timeout_ms": 10000 }, { "ok": true, "action": "assert_window_value", "ordinal": 4, "selector": null, "frame_selector": null, "optional": false, "path": "__neonMixProof.ratchetLoop.humanReviewPacket.ranking.role", "value": "review_order_only", "expected_value": "review_order_only", "timeout_ms": 10000 }, { "ok": true, "action": "assert_window_value", "ordinal": 5, "selector": null, "frame_selector": null, "optional": false, "path": "__neonMixProof.ratchetLoop.humanReviewPacket.request.candidateActionsAreTransient", "value": true, "expected_value": true, "timeout_ms": 10000 }, { "ok": true, "action": "screenshot", "ordinal": 6, "selector": null, "frame_selector": null, "optional": false, "label": "neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search", "screenshot_label": "lilarcade-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search-generated-prelim-candidate-desktop-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search", "full_page": false } ], "screenshot_label": "lilarcade-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search-generated-prelim-candidate-desktop", "screenshot_full_page": null } ], "console": { "events": [], "fatal_count": 0 }, "page_errors": [], "dialogs": [], "network_mocks": [], "dom_summary": { "expected_viewport_count": 1, "viewport_count": 1, "partial": false, "routes": [ { "requested": "https://main.dlwavl00q582x.amplifyapp.com/games/drum-sequencer?song=monkberry-moon-delight-tab&mix=profile&view=trainer&instrument=bass", "observed": "/games/drum-sequencer", "expected_path": "/games/drum-sequencer", "matched": true, "http_status": 200 } ], "titles": [ "LilArcade" ], "overflow_px": [ 0 ], "bounds_overflow_px": [ 0 ], "overflow_offender_counts": [ 0 ], "frames": [ { "viewport": "desktop", "selectors": [] } ], "http_status": [], "link_status": [], "route_inventory": [], "network_mock_count": 0, "network_mock_hit_count": 0, "dialog_count": 0, "dialog_accept_count": 0, "dialog_dismiss_count": 0 } } }