{ "version": "lilarcade.neon-ratchet-batch-summary.v1", "status": "candidate_ready_for_review", "ok": true, "deterministicOk": true, "allowFindings": true, "target": { "url": "https://main.dlwavl00q582x.amplifyapp.com", "route": "/games/drum-sequencer?song=monkberry-moon-delight-tab&mix=profile&view=trainer&instrument=bass" }, "preset": { "name": "candidate", "description": "Default local ratchet loop: deterministic gates plus bounded candidate review packet." }, "outputDir": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525", "coverage": null, "elapsedMs": 74398, "steps": [ { "id": "profile-sync", "kind": "profile_sync", "ok": true, "profileCount": 11, "changes": [], "errors": [], "error": null, "elapsedMs": 25, "stepLabel": "profile-sync" }, { "id": "claim-candidate-review", "kind": "profile_run", "ok": true, "exitCode": 0, "signal": null, "profilePath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/generated-profiles/ratchet-loop-from-batch-options.json", "outputDir": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/claim-candidate-review", "profileResultPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/claim-candidate-review/profile-result.json", "profile": { "profileName": "lilarcade-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search-generated-candidate", "status": "passed", "checkCount": 5 }, "error": null, "elapsedMs": 43419, "stepLabel": "claim-candidate-review" }, { "id": "human-review-packet", "kind": "human_review_packet", "ok": true, "proofPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/claim-candidate-review/proof.json", "outputDir": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/human-review-packet", "jsonPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/human-review-packet/human-review-packet.json", "markdownPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/human-review-packet/human-review-packet.md", "status": "candidate_ready_for_listening_review", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "requestedIntent": "turn the guitar part down a little", "selectedSong": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)", "recommendation": "guitar -0.05", "recommendationReason": "All objective claim receipts passed for this candidate; ranking only orders listening review.", "recommendationAction": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.6, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.05 }, "guardrails": { "supportedClaimCandidateCount": 2, "rejectedCandidateCount": 0, "stateRestoredAfterLoop": true, "noPermanentEditUnlessApplyBest": true, "approvedCandidateApplied": null }, "ranking": { "metric": "guardrail_preserving_section_energy_review_order", "role": "review_order_only", "lowerIsBetter": true, "baselineCandidateRankingMetric": 61.9694, "bestCandidateRankingMetric": 62.4946, "rankingMetricDelta": -0.5252, "sectionHeuristics": { "enabled": true, "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "loudnessStyle": "rms_dbfs_estimate", "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Section-energy and loudness-style metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." } }, "approval": null, "approvalMode": null, "approvedBy": null, "boundary": "Objective receipts support or reject candidate change claims; musical taste still requires listening review.", "elapsedMs": 11, "stepLabel": "human-review-packet" }, { "id": "mixing-canon-surrogate-review", "kind": "mixing_canon_surrogate_review", "ok": true, "outputDir": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/mixing-canon-surrogate-review", "jsonPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/mixing-canon-surrogate-review/mixing-canon-surrogate-review.json", "markdownPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/mixing-canon-surrogate-review/mixing-canon-surrogate-review.md", "status": "approved_for_development_application", "approval": { "mode": "mixing_canon_surrogate", "approvedBy": "codex", "basis": "Conservative mixing-canon development surrogate: review candidate guitar -0.05 sets guitar from 0.6 to 0.55 with absolute level delta <= 0.12 after objective receipts, section-energy guardrails, clipping/headroom/low-level checks, and state-restoration checks passed. This keeps development moving and still requires listening review before treating the result as a subjective mix preference." }, "approvalMode": "mixing_canon_surrogate", "approvedBy": "codex", "candidate": { "label": "guitar -0.05", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.6, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.05 } }, "failedChecks": [], "boundary": "A mixing-canon surrogate can approve a conservative candidate for development application only after objective receipts pass. It does not prove subjective mix quality.", "error": null, "review": { "version": "riddle-proof.mixing-canon-surrogate-review.v1", "kind": "mixing_canon_surrogate_review", "status": "approved_for_development_application", "ok": true, "approval": { "mode": "mixing_canon_surrogate", "approvedBy": "codex", "basis": "Conservative mixing-canon development surrogate: review candidate guitar -0.05 sets guitar from 0.6 to 0.55 with absolute level delta <= 0.12 after objective receipts, section-energy guardrails, clipping/headroom/low-level checks, and state-restoration checks passed. This keeps development moving and still requires listening review before treating the result as a subjective mix preference." }, "candidate": { "label": "guitar -0.05", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.6, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.05 } }, "checks": [ { "name": "packet_ready_for_listening_review", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "status": "candidate_ready_for_listening_review" } }, { "name": "recommended_set_mixer_level_candidate", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.6, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.05 } } }, { "name": "candidate_delta_is_conservative", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "absDelta": 0.05, "maxAbsLevelDelta": 0.12 } }, { "name": "objective_candidate_receipts_pass", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "receiptCount": 10, "passedReceiptCount": 10, "failedReceipts": [] } }, { "name": "candidate_matches_requested_direction", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "requestedDirection": "down", "targetMovement": { "rms": -0.00355, "peak": -0.0194, "totalEnergy": -0.000052 } } }, { "name": "section_energy_guardrails_preserved", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "requiredSectionEnergyComparison": true, "hasComparison": true, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0 } }, { "name": "packet_guardrails_preserved", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "supportedClaimCandidateCount": 2, "stateRestoredAfterLoop": true, "noPermanentEditUnlessApplyBest": true, "candidateGuardrails": { "mixerEditAccepted": true, "candidateTrackMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "candidateDirectionMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "contractLevelReflected": true, "renderedTargetMoved": true, "requiredInstrumentsPreserved": true, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "noClipping": true, "headroomPreserved": true, "noLowLevelProofWindow": true } } }, { "name": "ranking_is_review_order_only", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "rankingMetric": "guardrail_preserving_section_energy_review_order", "rankingRole": "review_order_only" } }, { "name": "taste_boundary_is_explicit", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "proofBoundary": "Objective receipts support or reject candidate change claims; musical taste still requires listening review.", "caveatCount": 5 } } ], "failedChecks": [], "boundary": "A mixing-canon surrogate can approve a conservative candidate for development application only after objective receipts pass. It does not prove subjective mix quality.", "caveats": [ "This approval surrogate is not a real listener preference.", "Use it to keep development moving when the candidate is subtle, reversible, metric-supported, and guardrail-preserving.", "Keep the final result framed as ready for listening review, not as a taste verdict." ], "doesNotProve": [ "subjective mix quality", "that a human listener prefers the candidate", "that the candidate is the best possible mix edit" ] }, "elapsedMs": 4, "stepLabel": "mixing-canon-surrogate-review" }, { "id": "approved-candidate", "kind": "profile_run", "ok": true, "exitCode": 0, "signal": null, "profilePath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/generated-profiles/approved-candidate-from-review.json", "outputDir": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/approved-candidate", "profileResultPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/approved-candidate/profile-result.json", "profile": { "profileName": "neon-step-sequencer-ratchet-loop-approved-candidate-from-review-packet", "status": "passed", "checkCount": 5 }, "error": null, "elapsedMs": 30927, "stepLabel": "approved-candidate" }, { "id": "approved-human-review-packet", "kind": "human_review_packet", "ok": true, "proofPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/approved-candidate/proof.json", "outputDir": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/approved-candidate/human-review-packet", "jsonPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/approved-candidate/human-review-packet/human-review-packet.json", "markdownPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/approved-candidate/human-review-packet/human-review-packet.md", "status": "candidate_applied_for_listening_review", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "requestedIntent": "apply reviewed candidate: guitar -0.05", "selectedSong": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)", "recommendation": "guitar -0.05", "recommendationReason": "All objective claim receipts passed for this candidate; ranking only orders listening review.", "recommendationAction": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.6, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.05 }, "guardrails": { "supportedClaimCandidateCount": 1, "rejectedCandidateCount": 0, "stateRestoredAfterLoop": true, "noPermanentEditUnlessApplyBest": false, "approvedCandidateApplied": true }, "ranking": { "metric": "guardrail_preserving_section_energy_review_order", "role": "review_order_only", "lowerIsBetter": true, "baselineCandidateRankingMetric": 61.9694, "bestCandidateRankingMetric": 62.4946, "rankingMetricDelta": -0.5252, "sectionHeuristics": { "enabled": true, "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "loudnessStyle": "rms_dbfs_estimate", "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Section-energy and loudness-style metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." } }, "approval": { "mode": "mixing_canon_surrogate", "approvedBy": "codex", "basis": "Conservative mixing-canon development surrogate: review candidate guitar -0.05 sets guitar from 0.6 to 0.55 with absolute level delta <= 0.12 after objective receipts, section-energy guardrails, clipping/headroom/low-level checks, and state-restoration checks passed. This keeps development moving and still requires listening review before treating the result as a subjective mix preference." }, "approvalMode": "mixing_canon_surrogate", "approvedBy": "codex", "boundary": "Objective receipts support or reject candidate change claims; musical taste still requires listening review.", "elapsedMs": 8, "stepLabel": "approved-human-review-packet" }, { "id": "durable-mix-patch-plan", "kind": "durable_mix_patch_plan", "ok": true, "outputDir": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/durable-mix-patch-plan", "jsonPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/durable-mix-patch-plan/durable-mix-patch-plan.json", "markdownPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/durable-mix-patch-plan/durable-mix-patch-plan.md", "status": "ready_for_durable_patch", "selectedSong": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)", "mixProfileId": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "candidate": { "label": "guitar -0.05", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.6, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.05 } }, "approval": { "mode": "mixing_canon_surrogate", "approvedBy": "codex", "basis": "Conservative mixing-canon development surrogate: review candidate guitar -0.05 sets guitar from 0.6 to 0.55 with absolute level delta <= 0.12 after objective receipts, section-energy guardrails, clipping/headroom/low-level checks, and state-restoration checks passed. This keeps development moving and still requires listening review before treating the result as a subjective mix preference." }, "sourceFile": "src/Games/songs/neon-approved-mix-overrides.json", "overrideId": "monkberry-moon-delight-tab-guitar-06-to-055-approved-candidate", "mixerLevels": { "guitar": 0.55 }, "errors": [], "boundary": "This is a durable patch handoff for an approved listening-review candidate. It does not prove subjective mix quality.", "error": null, "elapsedMs": 4, "stepLabel": "durable-mix-patch-plan" } ], "humanReviewPacket": { "id": "human-review-packet", "kind": "human_review_packet", "ok": true, "proofPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/claim-candidate-review/proof.json", "outputDir": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/human-review-packet", "jsonPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/human-review-packet/human-review-packet.json", "markdownPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/human-review-packet/human-review-packet.md", "status": "candidate_ready_for_listening_review", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "requestedIntent": "turn the guitar part down a little", "selectedSong": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)", "recommendation": "guitar -0.05", "recommendationReason": "All objective claim receipts passed for this candidate; ranking only orders listening review.", "recommendationAction": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.6, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.05 }, "guardrails": { "supportedClaimCandidateCount": 2, "rejectedCandidateCount": 0, "stateRestoredAfterLoop": true, "noPermanentEditUnlessApplyBest": true, "approvedCandidateApplied": null }, "ranking": { "metric": "guardrail_preserving_section_energy_review_order", "role": "review_order_only", "lowerIsBetter": true, "baselineCandidateRankingMetric": 61.9694, "bestCandidateRankingMetric": 62.4946, "rankingMetricDelta": -0.5252, "sectionHeuristics": { "enabled": true, "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "loudnessStyle": "rms_dbfs_estimate", "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Section-energy and loudness-style metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." } }, "approval": null, "approvalMode": null, "approvedBy": null, "boundary": "Objective receipts support or reject candidate change claims; musical taste still requires listening review.", "elapsedMs": 11, "stepLabel": "human-review-packet", "mixingCanonSurrogateReview": { "version": "riddle-proof.mixing-canon-surrogate-review.v1", "kind": "mixing_canon_surrogate_review", "status": "approved_for_development_application", "ok": true, "approval": { "mode": "mixing_canon_surrogate", "approvedBy": "codex", "basis": "Conservative mixing-canon development surrogate: review candidate guitar -0.05 sets guitar from 0.6 to 0.55 with absolute level delta <= 0.12 after objective receipts, section-energy guardrails, clipping/headroom/low-level checks, and state-restoration checks passed. This keeps development moving and still requires listening review before treating the result as a subjective mix preference." }, "candidate": { "label": "guitar -0.05", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.6, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.05 } }, "checks": [ { "name": "packet_ready_for_listening_review", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "status": "candidate_ready_for_listening_review" } }, { "name": "recommended_set_mixer_level_candidate", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.6, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.05 } } }, { "name": "candidate_delta_is_conservative", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "absDelta": 0.05, "maxAbsLevelDelta": 0.12 } }, { "name": "objective_candidate_receipts_pass", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "receiptCount": 10, "passedReceiptCount": 10, "failedReceipts": [] } }, { "name": "candidate_matches_requested_direction", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "requestedDirection": "down", "targetMovement": { "rms": -0.00355, "peak": -0.0194, "totalEnergy": -0.000052 } } }, { "name": "section_energy_guardrails_preserved", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "requiredSectionEnergyComparison": true, "hasComparison": true, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0 } }, { "name": "packet_guardrails_preserved", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "supportedClaimCandidateCount": 2, "stateRestoredAfterLoop": true, "noPermanentEditUnlessApplyBest": true, "candidateGuardrails": { "mixerEditAccepted": true, "candidateTrackMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "candidateDirectionMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "contractLevelReflected": true, "renderedTargetMoved": true, "requiredInstrumentsPreserved": true, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "noClipping": true, "headroomPreserved": true, "noLowLevelProofWindow": true } } }, { "name": "ranking_is_review_order_only", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "rankingMetric": "guardrail_preserving_section_energy_review_order", "rankingRole": "review_order_only" } }, { "name": "taste_boundary_is_explicit", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "proofBoundary": "Objective receipts support or reject candidate change claims; musical taste still requires listening review.", "caveatCount": 5 } } ], "failedChecks": [], "boundary": "A mixing-canon surrogate can approve a conservative candidate for development application only after objective receipts pass. It does not prove subjective mix quality.", "caveats": [ "This approval surrogate is not a real listener preference.", "Use it to keep development moving when the candidate is subtle, reversible, metric-supported, and guardrail-preserving.", "Keep the final result framed as ready for listening review, not as a taste verdict." ], "doesNotProve": [ "subjective mix quality", "that a human listener prefers the candidate", "that the candidate is the best possible mix edit" ] } }, "mixingCanonSurrogateReview": { "id": "mixing-canon-surrogate-review", "kind": "mixing_canon_surrogate_review", "ok": true, "outputDir": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/mixing-canon-surrogate-review", "jsonPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/mixing-canon-surrogate-review/mixing-canon-surrogate-review.json", "markdownPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/mixing-canon-surrogate-review/mixing-canon-surrogate-review.md", "status": "approved_for_development_application", "approval": { "mode": "mixing_canon_surrogate", "approvedBy": "codex", "basis": "Conservative mixing-canon development surrogate: review candidate guitar -0.05 sets guitar from 0.6 to 0.55 with absolute level delta <= 0.12 after objective receipts, section-energy guardrails, clipping/headroom/low-level checks, and state-restoration checks passed. This keeps development moving and still requires listening review before treating the result as a subjective mix preference." }, "approvalMode": "mixing_canon_surrogate", "approvedBy": "codex", "candidate": { "label": "guitar -0.05", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.6, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.05 } }, "failedChecks": [], "boundary": "A mixing-canon surrogate can approve a conservative candidate for development application only after objective receipts pass. It does not prove subjective mix quality.", "error": null, "review": { "version": "riddle-proof.mixing-canon-surrogate-review.v1", "kind": "mixing_canon_surrogate_review", "status": "approved_for_development_application", "ok": true, "approval": { "mode": "mixing_canon_surrogate", "approvedBy": "codex", "basis": "Conservative mixing-canon development surrogate: review candidate guitar -0.05 sets guitar from 0.6 to 0.55 with absolute level delta <= 0.12 after objective receipts, section-energy guardrails, clipping/headroom/low-level checks, and state-restoration checks passed. This keeps development moving and still requires listening review before treating the result as a subjective mix preference." }, "candidate": { "label": "guitar -0.05", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.6, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.05 } }, "checks": [ { "name": "packet_ready_for_listening_review", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "status": "candidate_ready_for_listening_review" } }, { "name": "recommended_set_mixer_level_candidate", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.6, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.05 } } }, { "name": "candidate_delta_is_conservative", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "absDelta": 0.05, "maxAbsLevelDelta": 0.12 } }, { "name": "objective_candidate_receipts_pass", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "receiptCount": 10, "passedReceiptCount": 10, "failedReceipts": [] } }, { "name": "candidate_matches_requested_direction", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "requestedDirection": "down", "targetMovement": { "rms": -0.00355, "peak": -0.0194, "totalEnergy": -0.000052 } } }, { "name": "section_energy_guardrails_preserved", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "requiredSectionEnergyComparison": true, "hasComparison": true, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0 } }, { "name": "packet_guardrails_preserved", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "supportedClaimCandidateCount": 2, "stateRestoredAfterLoop": true, "noPermanentEditUnlessApplyBest": true, "candidateGuardrails": { "mixerEditAccepted": true, "candidateTrackMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "candidateDirectionMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "contractLevelReflected": true, "renderedTargetMoved": true, "requiredInstrumentsPreserved": true, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "noClipping": true, "headroomPreserved": true, "noLowLevelProofWindow": true } } }, { "name": "ranking_is_review_order_only", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "rankingMetric": "guardrail_preserving_section_energy_review_order", "rankingRole": "review_order_only" } }, { "name": "taste_boundary_is_explicit", "ok": true, "severity": "required", "evidence": { "proofBoundary": "Objective receipts support or reject candidate change claims; musical taste still requires listening review.", "caveatCount": 5 } } ], "failedChecks": [], "boundary": "A mixing-canon surrogate can approve a conservative candidate for development application only after objective receipts pass. It does not prove subjective mix quality.", "caveats": [ "This approval surrogate is not a real listener preference.", "Use it to keep development moving when the candidate is subtle, reversible, metric-supported, and guardrail-preserving.", "Keep the final result framed as ready for listening review, not as a taste verdict." ], "doesNotProve": [ "subjective mix quality", "that a human listener prefers the candidate", "that the candidate is the best possible mix edit" ] }, "elapsedMs": 4, "stepLabel": "mixing-canon-surrogate-review" }, "approvedCandidatePacket": { "id": "approved-human-review-packet", "kind": "human_review_packet", "ok": true, "proofPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/approved-candidate/proof.json", "outputDir": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/approved-candidate/human-review-packet", "jsonPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/approved-candidate/human-review-packet/human-review-packet.json", "markdownPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/approved-candidate/human-review-packet/human-review-packet.md", "status": "candidate_applied_for_listening_review", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "requestedIntent": "apply reviewed candidate: guitar -0.05", "selectedSong": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)", "recommendation": "guitar -0.05", "recommendationReason": "All objective claim receipts passed for this candidate; ranking only orders listening review.", "recommendationAction": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.6, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.05 }, "guardrails": { "supportedClaimCandidateCount": 1, "rejectedCandidateCount": 0, "stateRestoredAfterLoop": true, "noPermanentEditUnlessApplyBest": false, "approvedCandidateApplied": true }, "ranking": { "metric": "guardrail_preserving_section_energy_review_order", "role": "review_order_only", "lowerIsBetter": true, "baselineCandidateRankingMetric": 61.9694, "bestCandidateRankingMetric": 62.4946, "rankingMetricDelta": -0.5252, "sectionHeuristics": { "enabled": true, "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "loudnessStyle": "rms_dbfs_estimate", "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Section-energy and loudness-style metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." } }, "approval": { "mode": "mixing_canon_surrogate", "approvedBy": "codex", "basis": "Conservative mixing-canon development surrogate: review candidate guitar -0.05 sets guitar from 0.6 to 0.55 with absolute level delta <= 0.12 after objective receipts, section-energy guardrails, clipping/headroom/low-level checks, and state-restoration checks passed. This keeps development moving and still requires listening review before treating the result as a subjective mix preference." }, "approvalMode": "mixing_canon_surrogate", "approvedBy": "codex", "boundary": "Objective receipts support or reject candidate change claims; musical taste still requires listening review.", "elapsedMs": 8, "stepLabel": "approved-human-review-packet" }, "durableMixPatchPlan": { "id": "durable-mix-patch-plan", "kind": "durable_mix_patch_plan", "ok": true, "outputDir": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/durable-mix-patch-plan", "jsonPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/durable-mix-patch-plan/durable-mix-patch-plan.json", "markdownPath": "/home/ec2-user/riddle-worktrees/lilarcade-neon-mixing-canon-surrogate/test-results/riddle-proof/neon-mixing-canon-surrogate-production-20260525/durable-mix-patch-plan/durable-mix-patch-plan.md", "status": "ready_for_durable_patch", "selectedSong": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)", "mixProfileId": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "candidate": { "label": "guitar -0.05", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.6, "to": 0.55, "delta": -0.05 } }, "approval": { "mode": "mixing_canon_surrogate", "approvedBy": "codex", "basis": "Conservative mixing-canon development surrogate: review candidate guitar -0.05 sets guitar from 0.6 to 0.55 with absolute level delta <= 0.12 after objective receipts, section-energy guardrails, clipping/headroom/low-level checks, and state-restoration checks passed. This keeps development moving and still requires listening review before treating the result as a subjective mix preference." }, "sourceFile": "src/Games/songs/neon-approved-mix-overrides.json", "overrideId": "monkberry-moon-delight-tab-guitar-06-to-055-approved-candidate", "mixerLevels": { "guitar": 0.55 }, "errors": [], "boundary": "This is a durable patch handoff for an approved listening-review candidate. It does not prove subjective mix quality.", "error": null, "elapsedMs": 4, "stepLabel": "durable-mix-patch-plan" }, "durableCurrentTarget": null, "findings": [], "nextAction": "Candidate loop passed; review the packet or run the promotion preset before deploy.", "boundary": "This batch proves deterministic app/audio guardrails and captures review packets. It does not prove subjective mix taste.", "artifactIndex": [ { "label": "Batch plan", "kind": "JSON plan", "path": "ratchet-batch-plan.json", "whyItMatters": "Records the configured preset, target, and ordered proof steps for this local batch." }, { "label": "Batch summary", "kind": "JSON summary", "path": "ratchet-batch-summary.json", "whyItMatters": "Structured rollup of step status, findings, review packet details, and next action." }, { "label": "Batch summary markdown", "kind": "Markdown summary", "path": "ratchet-batch-summary.md", "whyItMatters": "Human-readable local gate summary for deciding whether to continue, promote, or inspect findings." }, { "label": "claim-candidate-review profile result", "kind": "JSON profile result", "path": "claim-candidate-review/profile-result.json", "whyItMatters": "Structured Riddle Proof result for the claim-candidate-review batch step." }, { "label": "claim-candidate-review proof", "kind": "JSON proof", "path": "claim-candidate-review/proof.json", "whyItMatters": "Proof receipt for the claim-candidate-review batch step." }, { "label": "claim-candidate-review summary", "kind": "Markdown summary", "path": "claim-candidate-review/summary.md", "whyItMatters": "Human-readable proof summary for the claim-candidate-review batch step." }, { "label": "claim-candidate-review console", "kind": "JSON console log", "path": "claim-candidate-review/console.json", "whyItMatters": "Browser console evidence for the claim-candidate-review batch step." }, { "label": "claim-candidate-review artifact manifest", "kind": "JSON artifact manifest", "path": "claim-candidate-review/artifact-manifest.json", "whyItMatters": "Runner artifact manifest for the claim-candidate-review batch step." }, { "label": "claim-candidate-review screenshot", "kind": "Screenshot", "path": "claim-candidate-review/screenshots/lilarcade-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search-generated-candidate-desktop-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search.png", "whyItMatters": "Visual evidence captured during the claim-candidate-review batch step." }, { "label": "claim-candidate-review screenshot", "kind": "Screenshot", "path": "claim-candidate-review/screenshots/lilarcade-neon-ratchet-loop-mix-level-search-generated-candidate-desktop.png", "whyItMatters": "Visual evidence captured during the claim-candidate-review batch step." }, { "label": "approved-candidate profile result", "kind": "JSON profile result", "path": "approved-candidate/profile-result.json", "whyItMatters": "Structured Riddle Proof result for the approved-candidate batch step." }, { "label": "approved-candidate proof", "kind": "JSON proof", "path": "approved-candidate/proof.json", "whyItMatters": "Proof receipt for the approved-candidate batch step." }, { "label": "approved-candidate summary", "kind": "Markdown summary", "path": "approved-candidate/summary.md", "whyItMatters": "Human-readable proof summary for the approved-candidate batch step." }, { "label": "approved-candidate console", "kind": "JSON console log", "path": "approved-candidate/console.json", "whyItMatters": "Browser console evidence for the approved-candidate batch step." }, { "label": "approved-candidate artifact manifest", "kind": "JSON artifact manifest", "path": "approved-candidate/artifact-manifest.json", "whyItMatters": "Runner artifact manifest for the approved-candidate batch step." }, { "label": "approved-candidate screenshot", "kind": "Screenshot", "path": "approved-candidate/screenshots/neon-step-sequencer-ratchet-loop-approved-candidate-from-review-packet-desktop-neon-step-sequencer-ratchet-loop-approved-candidate.png", "whyItMatters": "Visual evidence captured during the approved-candidate batch step." }, { "label": "approved-candidate screenshot", "kind": "Screenshot", "path": "approved-candidate/screenshots/neon-step-sequencer-ratchet-loop-approved-candidate-from-review-packet-desktop.png", "whyItMatters": "Visual evidence captured during the approved-candidate batch step." }, { "label": "Human review packet", "kind": "Markdown review packet", "path": "human-review-packet/human-review-packet.md", "whyItMatters": "Reviewer-facing packet with recommendation, candidate rows, receipts, and proof/taste boundary." }, { "label": "Human review packet data", "kind": "JSON review packet", "path": "human-review-packet/human-review-packet.json", "whyItMatters": "Structured packet data behind the reviewer-facing Markdown." }, { "label": "Mixing canon surrogate review", "kind": "Markdown approval review", "path": "mixing-canon-surrogate-review/mixing-canon-surrogate-review.md", "whyItMatters": "Evidence-backed development approval surrogate for applying the review candidate without treating metrics as taste." }, { "label": "Mixing canon surrogate review data", "kind": "JSON approval review", "path": "mixing-canon-surrogate-review/mixing-canon-surrogate-review.json", "whyItMatters": "Structured checks that decide whether Codex can stand in for development approval." }, { "label": "Approved candidate packet", "kind": "Markdown review packet", "path": "approved-candidate/human-review-packet/human-review-packet.md", "whyItMatters": "Review packet for the approval-surrogate candidate application proof." }, { "label": "Approved candidate packet data", "kind": "JSON review packet", "path": "approved-candidate/human-review-packet/human-review-packet.json", "whyItMatters": "Structured approved-candidate review packet data." }, { "label": "Durable mix patch plan", "kind": "Markdown patch plan", "path": "durable-mix-patch-plan/durable-mix-patch-plan.md", "whyItMatters": "Human-readable durable patch handoff, not a subjective taste verdict." }, { "label": "Durable mix patch plan data", "kind": "JSON patch plan", "path": "durable-mix-patch-plan/durable-mix-patch-plan.json", "whyItMatters": "Structured durable patch handoff data." } ] }